1862-67] REALITY OF FUTURE LIFE 245
of futurity, and by their representation of the Divine Being
as naturally hostile to us, unless reconciled by Christ. I
don't know if I make myself intelligible. I think it is a
most utterly mistaken view that the doing away with the old
imagery of the future state makes it less real, and less enter-
ing into our everyday thoughts and calculations. On the
contrary, I believe that the now ordinary way of regarding
it as " a state, not a place," makes it immensely more real,
just because we can picture moral states, and also relation-
ships to others there, very distinctly, but cannot and never
could picture it as a place without stumbling on difficulties
directly. I am not now speaking of specially thoughtful or
religious people, but of the ordinary run of somewhat worldly
people, and I think what I say holds good of them, though,
of course, it does not apply to those who have distinct in-
tellectual doubts of a future life. I have been reading
lately, with intense interest, Liddon's " University Sermons,"
and recommend them to you. He is more High Church
than you will quite agree with, but the Sermons are full of
deep philosophic thought in exquisite language, and it is
refreshing to see how evidently, whether he is right or wrong,
he has formed his belief with full acquaintance with all the
arguments of various sceptical schools against it, whom he
quotes often. Indeed I have been much struck in seeing
how much more free and candid, in the sense ofreading and
trying to understand all that can be said on the other side,
the really thoughtful of the clergy are than the extreme so-
called Liberals, who are often as intolerant and unwilling to
study both sides as the Evangelicals themselves.
SUSANNA to SELINA
No date.
I went to a nice little dinner at the Elliots' on
Thursday to meet Miss Elliot. She told us of a dinner
which she had just been at where Carlyle was her gentle-
man and in high feather, but went on against all philan-
thropists like Miss Carpenter and Miss Elliot " spending
their lives trying to whitewash what God Almighty had