Eusebius is the first to tell us that the Ebionites used the
Gospel according to the Hebrews. Irenæus (Adv. Hær. I.
26. 2, III. 11. 7) says that they used the Gospel of Matthew, and the
fact that he mentions no difference between it and the canonical
Matthew shows that, so far as he knew, they were the same. But
according to Eusebius, Jerome, and Epiphanius the Gospel according to
the Hebrews was used by the Ebionites, and, as seen above (chap. 25,
note 18), this Gospel cannot have been identical with the canonical
Matthew. Either, therefore, the Gospel used by the Ebionites in the
time of Irenæus, and called by him simply the Gospel of Matthew,
was something different from the canonical Matthew, or else the
Ebionites had given up the Gospel of Matthew for another and a
different gospel (for the Gospel of the Hebrews cannot have been an
outgrowth of the canonical Matthew, as has been already seen, chap. 25,
note 24). The former is much more probable, and the difficulty may be
most simply explained by supposing that the Gospel according to the
Hebrews is identical with the so-called Hebrew Gospel of Matthew (see
chap. 24, note 5), or at least that it passed among the earliest Jewish
Christians under Matthew’s name, and that Irenæus, who was
personally acquainted with the sect, simply hearing that they used a
Gospel of Matthew, naturally supposed it to be identical with the
canonical Gospel. In the time of Jerome a Hebrew “Gospel
according to the Hebrews” was used by the “Nazarenes and
Ebionites” as the Gospel of Matthew (cf. in Matt. XII. 13;
Contra Pelag. III. 2). Jerome refrains from expressing his own
judgment as to its authorship, but that he did not consider it in its
existing form identical with the Hebrew Gospel of Matthew is clear from
his words in de vir. ill. chap. 3, taken in connection with the
fact that he himself translated it into Greek and Latin, as he states
in chap. 2. Epiphanius (Hær. XXIX. 9) says that the
Nazarenes still preserved the original Hebrew Matthew in full, while
the Ebionites (XXX. 13) had a Gospel of Matthew “not complete,
but spurious and mutilated”; and elsewhere (XXX. 3) he says that
the Ebionites used the Gospel of Matthew and called it the
“Gospel according to the Hebrews.” It is thus evident that
he meant to distinguish the Gospel of the Ebionites from that of the
Nazarenes, i.e. the Gospel according to the Hebrews from the original
Hebrew Matthew. So, likewise. Eusebius’ treatment of the Gospel
according to the Hebrews and of the Hebrew Gospel of Matthew clearly
indicates that he considered them two different gospels (cf. e.g. his
mention of the former in chap. 25 and in Bk. IV. chap. 22, and his
mention of the latter in chap. 24, and in Bk. IV. chap. 10). Of course
he knew that the former was not identical with the canonical Matthew,
and hence, naturally supposing that the Hebrew Matthew agreed with the
canonical Matthew, he could not do otherwise than make a distinction
between the Gospel according to the Hebrews and the Hebrew Matthew, and
he must therefore make the change which he did in Irenæus’
statement in mentioning the Gospel used by the Ebionites, as he knew
them. Moreover, as we learn from Bk. VI. chap. 17, the Ebionite
Symmachus had written against the Gospel of Matthew (of course the
canonical Gospel), and this fact would only confirm Eusebius in his
opinion that Irenæus was mistaken, and that the Ebionites did not
use the Gospel of Matthew.
But none of these facts militate
against the assumption that the Gospel of the Hebrews in its original
form was identical with the Hebrew Gospel of Matthew, or at least
passed originally under his name among Jewish Christians. For it is by
no means certain that the original Hebrew Matthew agreed with the
canonical Matthew, and, therefore, lack of resemblance between the
Gospel according to the Hebrews and the canonical Matthew is no
argument against its identity with the Hebrew Matthew. Moreover, it is
quite conceivable that, in the course of time, the original Gospel
according to the Hebrews underwent alterations, especially since it was
in the hands of a sect which was growing constantly more heretical, and
that, therefore, its resemblance to the canonical Matthew may have been
even less in the time of Eusebius and Jerome than at the beginning. It
is possible that the Gospel of Matthew, which Jerome claims to have
seen in the library at Cæsarea (de vir. ill. chap. 3), may
have been an earlier, and hence less corrupt, copy of the Gospel
according to the Hebrews.
Since the writing of
this note, Handmann’s work on the Gospel according to the Hebrews
(Das Hebräer-Evangelium, von Rudolf Handmann. Von Gebhardt
and Harnack’s Texte und Untersuchungen, Bd. V. Heft 3) has
come into my hands, and I find that he denies that that Gospel is to be
in any way identified with the traditional Hebrew Matthew, or that it
bore the name of Matthew. The reasons which he gives, however, are
practically the same as those referred to in this note, and, as already
shown, do not prove that the two were not originally identical.
Handmann holds that the Gospel among the Jewish Christians was called
simply “the Gospel,” or some general name of the kind, and
that it received from others the name “Gospel according to the
Hebrews,” because it was used by them. This may well be, but does
not militate at all against the existence of a tradition among the
Jewish Christians that Matthew was the author of their only gospel.
Handmann makes the Gospel according to the Hebrews a second independent
source of the Synoptic Gospels alongside of the
“Ur-Marcus,” (a theory which, if accepted, would go far to
establish its identity with the Hebrew Matthew), and even goes so far
as to suggest that it is to be identified with the λόγια of Papias (cf. the writer’s notice of Handmann’s book,
in the Presbyterian Review, July, 1889). For the literature on
this Gospel, see chap. 25, note 24. I find that Resch in his
Agrapha emphasizes the apocryphal character of the Gospel in its
original form, and makes it later than and in part dependent upon our
Matthew, but I am unable to agree with him.