β. Theology.
That there should be certain characteristic differences from the
theology of Athanasius is what one would expect in an account of Antony
that bore any relation to the historical person. Such is the
anthropomorphic tendency, shewn especially in the corporeal nature
ascribed to demons. Such perhaps is a tinge of naive semi-pelagianism
about the Hermit’s language (§20 and elsewhere); we cannot
forget the connection of Cassian’s Collations with Egyptian
monasticism. Once again, ‘Antony’s shame of the body is not
in the spirit of the writer ad Amunem’ (Gwatkin,
Studies, p. 102). Lastly, in Antony’s account of the
heathen gods (§76) we miss the characteristic Euhemerism of
Athanasius (see supra, pp. 10, 62, &c.). Throughout, in
fact, the ruder monastic instinct crops up from under the Athanasian
style and thought of the biographer. But the latter is also
unmistakable (see the notes passim), and the differences have
been certainly made too much of. I will give one example from Mr.
Gwatkin, who says (ubi supra), ‘Athanasius does not speak
of πρόνοια
like the Vita (c. 49, 66, 74), for de Fuga 25 specially
refers to his providential escape from Syrianus, and c. Gent.
47, πρόνοια
τῶν πάντων is
very incidental.’ Now certainly the constant introduction of
πρόνοια,
which Mr. Gwatkin has understated, is a marked feature of the
Vita. But I am not prepared to say that Athanasius could not
speak in this way. The word is common, and even characteristic, in his
writings. A few examples will support this statement; more will be
referred to in the index to this volume.