unchangeable, brings to pass the changes of all changeable things according to the desert
of their natures or of their actions. No one, therefore, would be so foolish as to deny that
Elias being a creature of God could be changed either for the worse or for the better; or that
by the will of the omnipotent God he could be changed in a manner unusual among men.
So we can have no reason for doubting what on the high authority of Scripture is related of
him, unless we limit the power of God to things which we are familiar with.
6. Faustus’ argument is, If Elias who was a man could escape death, why might not
Christ have the power of dying, since He was more than man? This is the same as to say,
If human nature can be changed for the better, why should not the divine nature be changed
for the worse?—a weak argument, seeing that human nature is changeable, while the divine
nature is not. Such a method of inference would lead to the glaring absurdity, that if God
can bestow eternal glory on man, He must also have the power of consigning Himself to
323
eternal misery. Faustus will reply that his argument refers only to three days of death for
God, as compared with eternal life for man. Well, if you understood the three days of death
in the sense of the death of the flesh which God took as a part of our mortal nature, you
would be quite correct; for the truth of the gospel makes known that the death of Christ for
three days was for the eternal life of men. But in arguing that there is no impropriety in
asserting a death of three days of the divine nature itself, without any assumption of mortality,
because human nature can be endowed with immortality, you display the folly of one who
knows neither God nor the gifts of God. And indeed, since you make part of your god to
be fastened to the mass of darkness for ever, how can you escape the absurd conclusion
already mentioned, that God consigns Himself to eternal misery? You will then require to
prove that part of light is light, while part of God is not God. To give you in a word, without
argument, the true reason of our faith, as regards Elias having been caught up to heaven
from the earth, though only a man, and as regards Christ being truly born of a virgin, and
truly dying on the cross, our belief in both cases is grounded on the declaration of Holy
Scripture,1001 which it is piety to believe, and impiety to disbelieve. What is said of Elias
you pretend to deny, for you will pretend anything. Regarding Christ, although even you
do not go the length of saying that He could not die, though He could be born, still you
deny His birth from a virgin, and assert His death on the cross to have been feigned, which
is equivalent to denying it too, except as a mockery for the delusion of men; and you allow
so much merely to obtain indulgence for your own falsehoods from the believers in these
fictions.
7. The question which Faustus makes it appear that he is asked by a Catholic, If Jesus
was not born, how could He die? could be asked only by one who overlooked the fact that
Adam died, though he was not born. Who will venture to say that the Son of God could
1001 2 Kings ii. 11; Matt. i. 25, xvii. 50.
550
Faustus insists that Jesus might have died though not born, by the exercise…