(1) Number of Festal Letters of
Athanasius.—This question, which is of first-rate importance
for the chronology of the period, must be regarded as settled, at any
rate until some discovery which shall revolutionise all existing data.
The number 45, which was the maximum known to antiquity The
very late Arabic Life of Ath. alone gives 47 (Migne xxv. p. ccli.), a
statement which we may safely ignore in view of the general character
of the document which is ‘crowded with incredible trivialities
and follies’ (Montf.), outbidding by far the ‘unparalleled
rubbish’ (id.) of the worst of the Greek biographies (see Migne
xxv. p. liv. sq.)., is confirmed by the Index, and by the fact
that the citations from Cosmas (see above) tally with the order of the
Letters in this Syriac version in every case where the letter is
preserved entire, while Letter 39, preserved by a different writer,
also tallies with the reference to it in the Index. It is therefore
unassailably established on our existing evidence that the last Easter
letter of Ath. was his ‘45th,’ in other words that 45 is
the full or normal number of his festal letters. This clinches
the reckoning of the Index and Hist. Aceph. that he was
bishop for 45 Easters (329–373 inclusive), i.e. for parts of 46
years (328–373 inclusive). Moreover it corroborates, and is
rivetted firm by, the statement of Cyril. Alex. Ep. 1, that
Athan. graced the see of Alexandria ‘fully 46 years.’
‘Il le dit en voulant faire son eloge: de sorte qu’il y a
tout lieu de croire qu’il n’a point passé les 46 ans:
car pour peu qu’il fust entré dans la 47me
année, S. Cyrille auroit dû naturellement luy
donner 47 ans The
italics are ours. Cf. Rufin. H. E. ii. 3, ‘xlvi
anno sacerdotii sui.’.’ So
Tillemont (viii. 719), whose opinion is all the more valuable from the
fact that he is unable to harmonise it with his date for the accession
of Ath., and accordingly forgets, p. 720 (sub. fin.), what he
has said on the previous page.