Chapter XII.—The
Explanation of the Passage Offered by the Psychics
Considered.
Listen, withal, to the very subtle argumentation
on the contrary side. “So true is it,” say (our
opponents), “that the apostle has permitted the iteration of
marriage, that it is only such as are in the Clerical Order that he has
stringently bound to the yoke of monogamy. For that which he
prescribes to certain (individuals) he does not prescribe to
all.” Does it then follow, too, that to bishops alone he
does
not
prescribe what he does enjoin upon all; if what he does
prescribe to bishops he does
not
enjoin upon all? or is it
therefore
to all
because
to bishops? and
therefore
to bishops
because
to all? For whence is it that the
bishops and clergy come? Is it not from
all
? If
all
are not bound to monogamy, whence are monogamists (to be
taken) into the clerical rank? Will some separate order of
monogamists have to be instituted, from which to make selection for the
clerical body? (No); but when we are extolling and inflating
ourselves in opposition to the clergy, then “we are all
one:” then “we are all priests, because He hath made
us priests to (His) God and Father.” When we are challenged
to a thorough equalization with the sacerdotal discipline, we lay down
the (priestly) fillets, and (still) are on a par! The question in
hand (when the apostle was writing), was with reference to
Ecclesiastical Orders—what son of men ought to be ordained.
It was therefore fitting that all the form of the common discipline
should be set forth on its fore-front, as an edict to be in a certain
sense universally and carefully attended to, that the laity might the
better know that they must themselves observe that order which was
indispensable to their overseers; and that even the office of honour
itself might not flatter itself in anything tending to licence, as if
on the ground of privilege of position. The Holy Spirit foresaw
that some would say, “All things are lawful to bishops;”
just as that bishop of Utina of yours feared not even the Scantinian
law. Why, how many digamists, too, preside in your churches;
insulting the apostle, of course: at all events, not blushing
when these passages are read under their presidency!
Come, now, you who think that an exceptional law
of monogamy is made with reference to bishops, abandon withal your
remaining disciplinary titles, which, together with monogamy, are
ascribed to bishops.
668
Refuse to be
“irreprehensible, sober, of good morals, orderly, hospitable,
easy to be taught;” nay, indeed, (be) “given to wine,
prompt with the hand to strike, combative, money-loving, not ruling
your house, nor caring for your children’s
discipline,”—no, nor “courting good renown even from
strangers.” For if bishops have a law of their own teaching
monogamy, the other (characteristics) likewise, which will be the
fitting concomitants of monogamy, will have been written (exclusively)
for bishops. With laics, however, to whom monogamy is not
suitable, the other (characteristics) also have nothing to do.
(Thus), Psychic, you have (if you please) evaded the bonds of
discipline in its entirety! Be consistent in prescribing, that
“what is enjoined upon certain (individuals) is not enjoined upon
all;” or else, if the other (characteristics) indeed are common,
but monogamy is imposed upon bishops alone, (tell me), pray, whether
they
alone are to be pronounced
Christians
upon whom is
conferred the entirety of discipline?
668
See
1 Tim. iii. 1–7; Tit. i.
6–9
.