The Teacher answered: The
expressions of that narrative of the Word are certainly material; but
still many hints are interspersed in it to rouse the skilled inquirer
to a more discriminating study of it. I mean that He Who parts the good
from the bad by a great gulf, and makes the man in torment crave for a
drop to be conveyed by a finger, and the man who has been ill-treated
in this life rest on a patriarch’s bosom, and Who relates their
previous death and consignment to the tomb, takes an intelligent
searcher of His meaning far beyond a superficial interpretation. For
what sort of eyes has the Rich Man to lift up in hell,
when he has left his bodily eyes in that tomb? And how can a
disembodied spirit feel any flame? And what sort of tongue can he crave
to be cooled with the drop of water, when he has lost his tongue of
flesh? What is the finger that is to convey to him this drop? What sort
of place is the “bosom” of repose? The bodies of both of
them are in the tomb, and their souls are disembodied, and do not
consist of parts either; and so it is impossible to make the framework
of the narrative correspond with the truth, if we understand it
literally; we can do that only by translating each detail into an
equivalent in the world of ideas. Thus we must think of the gulf as
that which parts ideas which may not be confounded from running
together, not as a chasm of the earth. Such a chasm, however vast it
were, could be traversed with no difficulty by a disembodied
intelligence; since intelligence can in no time ἀχρόνως. be
wherever it will.