3. Since this is so, and since no strange influence has suddenly manifested itself to break
the continuous course of events by interrupting their succession, what is the ground of the
allegation, that a plague was brought upon the earth after the Christian religion came into
the world, and after it revealed the mysteries of hidden truth? But pestilences, say my oppon-
ents, and droughts, wars, famines, locusts, mice, and hailstones, and other hurtful things,
by which the property of men is assailed, the gods bring upon us, incensed as they are by
your wrong-doings and by your transgressions. If it were not a mark of stupidity to linger
on matters which are already clear, and which require no defence, I should certainly show,
by unfolding the history of past ages, that those ills which you speak of were not unknown,
were not sudden in their visitation; and that the plagues did not burst upon us, and the affairs
of men begin to be attacked by a variety of dangers, from the time that our sect3246 won the
honour3247 of this appellation. For if we are to blame, and if these plagues have been devised
against our sin, whence did antiquity know these names for misfortunes? Whence did she
give a designation to wars? By what conception could she indicate pestilence and hailstorms,
or how could she introduce these terms among her words, by which speech was rendered
plain? For if these ills are entirely new, and if they derive their origin from recent transgres-
sions, how could it be that the ancients coined terms for these things, which, on the one
hand, they knew that they themselves had never experienced, and which, on the other, they
had not heard of as occurring in the time of their ancestors? Scarcity of produce, say my
opponents, and short supplies of grain, press more heavily on us. For, I would ask, were the
former generations, even the most ancient, at any period wholly free from such an inevitable
calamity? Do not the very words by which these ills are characterized bear evidence and
proclaim loudly that no mortal ever escaped from them with entire immunity? But if the
matter were difficult of belief, we might urge, on the testimony of authors, how great nations,
and what individual nations, and how often such nations experienced dreadful famine, and
perished by accumulated devastation. Very many hailstorms fall upon and assail all things.
For do we not find it contained and deliberately stated in ancient literature, that even showers
of stones3248 often ruined entire districts? Violent rains cause the crops to perish, and pro-
claim barrenness to countries:—were the ancients, indeed, free from these ills, when we
have known of3249 mighty rivers even being dried up, and the mud of their channels parched?
3246 Or, “race,” gens, i.e., the Christian people.
3247 The verb mereri, used in this passage, has in Roman writers the idea of merit or excellence of some kind
in a person, in virtue of which he is deemed worthy of some favour or advantage; but in ecclesiastical Latin it
means, as here, to gain something by the mere favour of God, without any merit of one’s own.
3248 See Livy, i. 31, etc.; and Pliny, Nat. Hist., ii. 38.
3249 The ms. reads, flumina cognoverimus ingentia lim-in-is ingentia siccatis, “that mighty rivers shrunk up,
leaving the mud,” etc.
Chapter III.
919
Chapter III.