LANGUAGE AND LITERATURE
plained that it created an inequality between the Colleges, and
was likely to leave their schools of philosophy " desolate." It
should have been founded, if at all, in a neutral place. The
master of the Grammar School also complained later that the
"
private school" of Humanity at St. Leonard's damaged him by
drawing away his best pupils. It is to be noted that the term"
private school " at this date means " tutorial class " as opposed
to the " public schools " or formal lectures. The fact that the
new professor taught instead of " reading," that is, dictating in
the medieval way, is regularly put in the forefront of the com-
plaints that were made.
In 164 1 a Commission, consisting mostly of old St. Salvator's
men, was appointed, and they ordained that the new professor
should teach in some neutral part of the town and that he
should not be allowed to teach "grammar" even in his chamber.
He was also to take rank below the four philosophy regents.
All this seemed very satisfactory, no doubt, but the regents
forgot that they had to deal with a Senator of the College of
Justice and " Director of the Chancellary." He was a St.
Leonard's man, and he knew the sort of people they were. We
may be sure too that the author of that chronique scandaleuse,
The Staggering State of Scottish Statesmen, had a keen eye for
sinister intrigues. In any case, he had very prudently inserted a
" clause irritant " in the deed of foundation, and he now raised a
summons of declarator, and had the whole transaction made null
and void. The College had to refund the money and the chair
was abolished. That was not enough for Lord Scotstarvit, how-
ever. He was determined that St. Leonard's should have a
Chair of Humanity, whether the regents liked it or not, and in
1644 he petitioned Parliament to re-establish the chair in such a
way as to exclude effectually the possibility of his wishes being
disregarded. The petition was granted and the Act was passed.
Thereupon the regents of St. Salvator's, who had been making
141