τῶν γονέων
τῶν ἑαυτῶν
τὴν
αἵρεσιν.
Latin: parentum suorum sectam. There has been some discussion as
to whether Galerius here refers to primitive Christianity or to
paganism, but the almost unanimous opinion of scholars (so far as I am
aware) is that he means the former (cf. among others, Mason, p. 298
sq.). I confess myself, however, unable, after careful study of the
document, to accept this interpretation. Not that I think it impossible
that Galerius should pretend that the cause of the persecution had been
the departure of the Christians from primitive Christianity, and its
object the reform of the Church, because, although that was certainly
not his object, he may nevertheless, when conquered, have wished to
make it appear so to the Christians at least (see Mason, p. 302 sq.).
My reason for not accepting the interpretation is that I cannot see
that the language of the edict warrants it; and certainly, inasmuch as
it is not what we should a priori expect Galerius to say, we are
hardly justified in adopting it except upon very clear grounds. But in
my opinion such grounds do not exist, and in fact the interpretation
seems to me to do violence to at least a part of the decree. In the
present sentence it is certainly not necessarily implied that
the ancestors of the Christians held a different religion from the
ancestors of the heathen; in fact, it seems on the face of it more
natural to suppose that Galerius is referring to the earlier ancestors
of both Christians and heathen, who were alike pagans. This is
confirmed by the last clause of the sentence: ad bonas mentes
redirent (εἰς
ἀγαθήν
πρόθεσιν
ἐπανέλθοιεν), which in the mouth of Galerius, and indeed of any
heathen, would naturally mean “return to the worship of our
gods.” This in itself, however, proves nothing, for Galerius may,
as is claimed, have used the words hypocritically; but in the next
sentence, which is looked upon as the main support of the
interpretation which I am combating, it is not said that they have
deserted their ancient institutions in distinction from the
institutions of the rest of the world, but illa veterum
instituta (a term which he could hardly employ in this unqualified
way to indicate the originators of Christianity without gross and
gratuitous insult to his heathen subjects) quæ forsitan primum
parentes eorumdem constituerant, “those institutions of the
ancients which perchance their own fathers had first
established” (the Greek is not quite accurate, omitting the
demonstrative, and reading πρότερον for primum). There can hardly have been a
“perchance” about the fact that the Christians’
ancestors had first established Christian institutions, whatever they
were—certainly Galerius would never have thought of implying that
his ancestors, or the ancestors of his brother-pagans, had established
them. His aim seems to be to suggest, as food for reflection, not only
that the ancestors of the Christians had certainly, with the ancestors
of the heathen, originally observed pagan institutions, but that
perhaps they had themselves been the very ones to establish those
institutions, which would make the guilt of the Christians in departing
from them all the worse. In the next clause, the reference to the
Christians as making laws for themselves and assembling in various
places may as easily be a rebuke to the Christians for their separation
from their heathen fellow-citizens in matters of life and worship as a
rebuke to them for their departure from the original unity of the
Christian Church. Again, in the next sentence the “institutions
of the ancients” (veterum instituta) are referred to in
the most general way, without any such qualification as could possibly
lead the Christians or any one else to think that the institutions of
the Christian religion were meant. Conformity to “the ancient
laws and public discipline of the Romans” is announced in the
beginning of the edict as the object which Galerius had in view. Could
he admit, even for the sake of propitiating his Christian subjects,
that those laws and that discipline were Christian? Veterum
instituta in fact could mean to the reader nothing else, as thus
absolutely used, than the institutions of the old Romans.
Still further it is to
be noticed that in §9 Galerius does not say “but
although many persevere in their purpose…nevertheless,
in consideration of our philanthropy, we have determined that we ought
to extend our indulgence,” &c., but rather “and
since (atque cum) many persevere in their purpose,”
&c. The significance of this has apparently been hitherto quite
overlooked. Does he mean to say that he feels that he ought to extend
indulgence just because they do exactly what they did
before—worship neither the gods of the heathen nor the God of the
Christians? I can hardly think so. He seems to me to say rather,
“Since many, in spite of my severe measures, still persevere in
their purpose (in proposito perseverarent) and refuse to worship
our gods, while at the same time they cease under the pressure to
worship their own God as they have been accustomed to do, I have
decided to permit them to return to their own worship, thinking it
better that they worship the God of the Christians than that they
worship no God; provided in worshiping him they do nothing contrary to
discipline (contra disciplinam), i.e. contrary to Roman
law.” Thus interpreted, the entire edict seems to me consistent
and at the same time perfectly natural. It is intended to propitiate
the Christians and to have them pray for the good of the emperor to
their own God, rather than refuse to pray for him altogether. It is not
an acknowledgment even to the Christians that their God is the supreme
and only true God, but it is an acknowledgment that their God is
probably better than no god, and that the empire will be better off if
they become loyal, peaceable, prayerful citizens again (even if their
prayers are not directed to the highest gods), than if they continue
disaffected and disloyal and serve and worship no superior being. That
the edict becomes, when thus interpreted, much more dignified and much
more worthy of an emperor cannot be denied; and, little respect as we
may have for Galerius, we should not accuse him of playing the
hypocrite and the fool in this matter, except on better grounds than
are offered by the extant text of this edict.