SECT. V.
Of errors connected with lay-exhorting.
Another thing, in the management of which there has been much error and misconduct,
is lay-exhorting; about which there has been abundance of disputing, jangling, and conten-
tion. In the midst of these disputes, I suppose that all are agreed as to these two things, viz.
1. That all exhorting one another by lay-men is not unlawful or improper; but, on the con-
trary, that such exhorting is a Christian duty. And, 2. I suppose also, all will allow that there
is some kind or way of exhorting and teaching which belongs only to the office of teachers.
All will allow that God has appointed such an office as that of teachers in the christian church,
and therefore doubtless will allow that something or other is proper and peculiar to that
office, or some business of teaching that does not belong as much to others as to them. If
there be any way of teaching that is peculiar to that office, then for others to take that upon
them, is to invade the office of a minister; which doubtless is very sinful, and is often so
represented in Scripture. But the great difficulty is to settle the bounds, and to tell exactly
how far lay-men may go, and when they exceed their limits; which is a matter of so much
difficulty, that I do not wonder if many in their zeal have transgressed. The two ways of
teaching and exhorting, the one of which ought ordinarily to be left to ministers, and the
other of which may and ought to be practised by the people, may be expressed by those two
name of preaching, and exhorting in way of christian conversation. But then a great deal of
difficulty and controversy arises to determine what is preaching, and what is christian con-
versation. However, I will humbly offer my thoughts concerning this subject of lay-exhorting,
as follows.
I. The common people, in exhorting one another, ought not to clothe themselves with
the like authority with that which is proper for ministers. There is a certain authority that
ministers have and should exercise in teaching, as well as in governing the flock. Teaching
is spoken of in Scripture as an act of authority, 1 Tim. ii. 12. In order to a man’s preaching,
special authority must be committed to him, “How shall they preach, except they be sent?”
Ministers in this work of teaching and exhorting are clothed with authority, as Christ’s
messengers, Mal. ii. 7. as representing him, and so speaking in his name, and in his stead,
2 Cor. v. 18-20. And it seems to be the most honourable thing that belongs to the office of
a minister of the gospel, that to him is committed the word of reconciliation, and that he
has power to preach the gospel, as Christ’s messenger, and speaking in his name. The apostle
seems to speak of it as such, 1 Cor. i. 16, 17. Ministers therefore, in the exercise of this power,
may clothe themselves with authority in speaking, or may teach others in an authoritative
manner, “These things speak and exhort, and rebuke with all authority; Let no man despise
thee.” But the common people, in exhorting one another, ought not thus to exhort in an
authoritative manner. There is a great deal of difference between teaching as a father amongst
a company of children, and counselling in a brotherly way, as the children may kindly
SECTION V. Errors relative to lay-exhorting.
1703
SECTION V. Errors relative to lay-exhorting.