In the collection of his facts Socrates everywhere tried
to reach primary sources. A great portion of his work is drawn from
oral tradition, the accounts given by friends and countrymen, the
common, but not wild, rumors of the capital, and the transient
literature of the day. Whenever he depends on such information,
Socrates attempts to reach as far as possible the accounts of
eye-witnesses,
I. Int.; V. 19; VI. Int.
and appends any doubts he may have as to the truth of the statements
they make. Of written works he has used for the period where his work
and that of Eusebius overlap the latter’s Ecclesiastical
History and Life of Constantine;
I. 8.
for other events he follows Rufinus,
I. 12, 19; II. 1; III. 19; IV. 24, 26.
abandoning him, however, in his second edition, whenever he conflicts
with more trustworthy authorities. He has also made use of
Archelaus’ Acts,
I. 22.
of Sabinus’ Collection of the Acts of the Synods, which he
criticises for unfairness,
I. 8; II. 15, 17, 20; III. 10, 25; IV. 12, 22.
Epiphanius’ Ancoratus,
V. 24.
George of Laodicea,
I. 24.
Athanasius’ Apolog.,
II. 28; III. 8.
de Syn.,
II. 37.
and de Decr. Nic.,
VI. 13.
Evagrius,
III. 7.
Palladius,
IV. 23.
Nestorius,
VII. 19–24.
and Origen.
III. 7.
Christian writers before Origen are
known to him and mentioned by him, such as Irenæus, Clement of
Alexandria, Apollinaris the Elder, Serapion, and others; but he does
not seem to have used their works as sources, probably because they
threw no light on the subject at hand, his period being entirely
different from that in which they flourished. Besides these writers,
Socrates has also used public documents, pastoral and episcopal
letters, decrees, acts, and other documents not previously incorporated
in written works. Some of these the author has used, but does not quote
in extenso, on account of their length.
II. 17.
Of the sources that he might have used, but has not, may be mentioned
Dexippus, Eunapius (χρονικὴ
ἱστορία), Olympiodorus
(λόγοι
ἱστορικοί), and
especially Zosimus, his contemporary (ἱστορία νέα).
Whether these were unknown to him, or whether he deemed it unnecessary
to make use of the information given by them, or considered them
untrustworthy, it cannot be ascertained. It is sufficient to say that
for the period he covers, and the geographical limitation he has put on
his work, his array of facts is sufficiently large and to the purpose.
The use he makes of these facts also shows sufficiently the historian
as thorough as he could be considering the time and environment in
which he flourished. There is an evident attempt throughout his work at
precision. He marks the succession of bishops, the years in which each
event took place by the consulships and Olympiads of Roman and Greek
history. He has made painstaking investigations on various topics, such
as the different usages in various localities, respecting the
observance of Easter, the performance of the rites of baptism and
marriage, the manner of fasting, of church assemblies, and other
ecclesiastical usages.
V. 22.
His accuracy has been questioned from the time of Photius
Phot. Biblioth. Cod. 28.
ἀλλὰ καὶ ἐν
τοῖς δόγμασι
οὐ λίαν
ἀκριβής. Whether in this phrase he
meant to accuse Socrates with inaccuracy in the narration of facts or
indifference to theological dogma is not very clear. Probably the
former.
to our own days. It cannot be denied that there are a number of errors
in the History. He confused Maximian and Maximin.
I. 2.
He ascribes three ‘Creeds’ to the first Council of Sirmium,
whereas these belonged to other councils. In general he is confused on
the individuals to whom he ascribes the authorship of the Sirmian
creeds.
II. 30.
Similar confusion and lack of trustworthiness is noticed in his version
of the sufferings of Paul of Constantinople and the vicissitudes of the
life of Athanasius. He has wrongly given the number of those who
dissented from the decision of the Council of Nicæa as five. The
letter of the Council only mentions two,—Theonas and Secundus.
The exile of Eusebius and Theognis is ascribed to a later period and a
different cause by Jerome and Philostorgius, and it is generally
conceded that Socrates’ information was erroneous on this subject
also. He is incorrect on several particulars in the lives of Basil and
Gregory of Nazianzus, as also in assigning the attack at night on the
church of St. Theonas to the usurpation of Gregory, the Arian bishop of
Alexandria.
II. 11.