It may indeed be undignified to give any answer at all to the statements that are foolish;
we seem to be pointed that way by Solomon’s wise advice, “not to answer a fool according
to his folly.” But there is a danger lest through our silence error may prevail over the truth,
and so the rotting sore1221 of this heresy may invade it, and make havoc of the sound word
of the faith. It has appeared to me, therefore, to be imperative to answer, not indeed according
to the folly of these men who offer objections of such a description to our Religion, but for
the correction of their depraved ideas. For that advice quoted above from the Proverbs gives,
I think, the watchword not for silence, but for the correction of those who are displaying
some act of folly; our answers, that is, are not to run on the level of their foolish conceptions,
but rather to overturn those unthinking and deluded views as to doctrine.
What then is the charge they bring against us? They accuse us of profanity for entertain-
ing lofty conceptions about the Holy Spirit. All that we, in following the teachings of the
Fathers, confess as to the Spirit, they take in a sense of their own, and make it a handle
against us, to denounce us for profanity1222. We, for instance, confess that the Holy Spirit
is of the same rank as the Father and the Son, so that there is no difference between them
in anything, to be thought or named, that devotion can ascribe to a Divine nature. We
confess that, save His being contemplated as with peculiar attributes in regard of Person,
the Holy Spirit is indeed from God, and of the Christ, according to Scripture1223, but that,
while not to be confounded with the Father in being never originated, nor with the Son in
being the Only-begotten, and while to be regarded separately in certain distinctive properties,
316
He has in all else, as I have just said, an exact identity1224 with them. But our opponents
aver that He is a stranger to any vital communion with the Father and the Son; that by
reason of an essential variation He is inferior to, and less than they in every point; in power,
in glory, in dignity, in fine in everything that in word or thought we ascribe to Deity; that,
in consequence, in their glory He has no share, to equal honour with them He has no claim;
1221 σηπεδονώδης…γάγγραινα: both used by Galen.
1222 εἰς ἀσεβείαν γράφειν. This is Mai’s reading. Cf. ἀσεβείας γραφή. The active (instead of middle) in this
sense is found in Aristoph. Av. 1052: the passive is not infrequent in Demosthenes and Æschines.
1223 From God, and of the Christ, according to Scripture. This is noticeable. The Greek is ἐκ τοῦ Θεοῦ ἐστι,
καὶ τοῦ Χριστοῦ ἐστι, καθὼς γέγραπται. Compare the words below “proceeding from the Father, receiving from
the Son.”
1224 τὸ ἀπαράλλακτον (but there is something lost before this: perhaps τὸ ἡνωμένον). This word is used to
express substantial identity. Origen uses it in alluding to the “Stoic resurrection,” i.e. the time when the “Great
Year” shall again begin, and the world’s history be literally repeated, i.e. the “identical Socrates shall marry the
identical Xantippe, and teach the identical philosophy, &c.” This expression was a favourite one also with
Chrysostom and Cyril of Alexandria to express the identity of Glory, of Godhead, and of Honour, in the Blessed
Trinity.
588
On the Holy Spirit.