This act of Origen’s has been greatly discussed, and some
have even gone so far as to believe that he never committed the act,
but that the report of it arose from a misunderstanding of certain
figurative expressions used by him (so, e.g., Boehringer, Schnitzer,
and Baur). There is no reason, however, to doubt the report, for which
we have unimpeachable testimony, and which is in itself not at all
surprising (see the arguments of Redepenning, I. p. 444 sqq.). The act
was contrary to the civil law (see Suetonius, Domitian, c. 7;
and cf. Justin Martyr, Apol. I. 29), and yet was a very common
one; the existence of the law itself would alone prove what we know
from many sources to have been the fact. Nor was Origen alone among the
Christians (cf. e.g. Origen, In Matt., XV. 1, the passage of
Justin Martyr referred to above, and also the first canon of the
Council of Nicæa, the very existence of which proves the necessity
of it). It was natural that Christians, seeking purity of life, and
strongly ascetic in their tendencies, should be influenced by the
actions of those about them, who sought thus to be freed from the
domination of the passions, and should interpret certain passages of
the Bible as commending the act. Knowing it to be so common, and
knowing Origen’s character, as revealed to us in chap. 3, above
(to say nothing of his own writings), we can hardly be surprised that
he performed the act. His chief motive was undoubtedly the same as that
which actuated him in all his ascetic practices, the attainment of
higher holiness through the subjugation of his passions, and the desire
to sacrifice everything fleshly for the sake of Christ. Of course this
could not have led him to perform the act he did, unless he had
entirely misunderstood, as Eusebius says he did, the words of Christ
quoted below. But he was by no means the only one to misunderstand them
(see Suicer’s Thesaurus, I. 1255 sq.). Eusebius says that
the requirements of his position also had something to do with his
resolve. He was obliged to teach both men and women, and both day and
night (as we learn from §7), and Eusebius thinks he would
naturally desire to avoid scandal. At the same time, this motive can
hardly have weighed very heavily, if at all, with him; for had his
giving instruction in this way been in danger of causing serious
scandal, other easier methods of avoiding such scandal might have been
devised, and undoubtedly would have been, by the bishop. And the fact
is, he seems to have wished to conceal the act, which is inconsistent
with the idea that he performed it for the sake of avoiding scandal. It
is quite likely that his intimate association with women may have had
considerable to do with his resolve, because he may have found that
such association aroused his unsubdued passions, and therefore felt
that they must be eradicated, if he was to go about his duties with a
pure and single heart. That he afterward repented his youthful act, and
judged the words of Christ more wisely, is clear from what he says in
his Comment. in Matt. XV. 1. And yet he never outgrew his false
notions of the superior virtue of an ascetic life. His act seems to
have caused a reaction in his mind which led him into doubt and
despondency for a time; for Demetrius found it necessary to exhort him
to cherish confidence, and to urge him to continue his work of
instruction. Eusebius, while not approving Origen’s act, yet
evidently admired him the more for the boldness and for the spirit of
self-sacrifice shown in its performance.