Arianism was the
result of a strong opposition to Sabellianism, coupled with a
misunderstanding of the argument against it. There was, no doubt,
a danger of falling into the opposite error of Tritheism, to avoid
which Arianism “divided the Substance” and
virtually—and in the end explicity—denied the Godhead of
our Lord Jesus Christ. Arius was a Priest of Alexandria, and it
was there that he began to publish his opinions, in the early years of
the Fourth Century (318); but Newman traces the origin of the heresy to
Antioch and its Judaizing tendency. At a meeting of the clergy in
Alexandria the Bishop, S. Alexander, gave an address on the coeternity,
and coequality of the Father and the Son, and used the expression
τὴν
αὐτὴν οὐσίαν
ἔχειν, that They had the same
Substance. Arius protested against this as a Sabellian statement,
and used the words κτίσμα (creature) and
ποίημα (a thing made) of
the Son, adding the sentence which became so famous, ἦν
ὅτε οὐκ
ἦν,—there was a time when the Son did not
exist. Having ineffectually tried private remonstrance, S.
Alexander brought the matter in 321 before his Provincial Synod, in
which were present about 100 Egyptian and Pentapolitan Bishops, who
after giving the matter a patient hearing, excommunicated Arius and his
principal adherents. But it was too late to undo the
mischief. The heresy spread widely, and the whole Eastern Church
was stirred by the controversy. At last a great Council of the
whole Church met at Nicæa in 325, summoned by the Emperor; and
there the heresy was unequivocally condemned, and the great Creed
propounded with its watchword, the Homoousion. The false teaching
had however struck its roots deep and wide; and though now banned by
the anathema of the Church, it was long in dying; and indeed at one
time, it seemed as if—humanly speaking—it must swamp the
whole Catholic Church. Under various forms the Semi-Arians who
claimed to differ from the faith of Nicæa only by a single letter,
the Aetians and Eunomians, who went to the furthest extreme of the
Falsehood (Anomœans), and many others, the heresy spread far and
wide: and when S. Gregory came to Constantinople there was not
one Catholic Church or Priest to be found in the place, and only a few
scattered folk who still held to the Faith of the Consubstantial.
Gregory’s wonderful discourses however came to their aid, and
partly under his presidency was held the Second Œcumenical Synod,
which condemned the heresy of Macedonius, a still further development
of Arianism, which denied also the Deity of the Holy Ghost.
Arianism survived for another two centuries among the Goths and
Vandals, the Burgundians and Lombards; but it never rose again as a
power in the Church.