of his saintship, and by which gracious sincerity is certainly distinguished from every thing
else.” And, (p. 141. a.) “The notion of men’s being able and fit to determine positively the
condition of other men, or the certainty of their gracious state, has a direct tendency to de-
ceive the souls of men.” And thus Mr. W. makes mention of a positive judgment above forty
times in his book, with reference to my use of it, and to my declared opinion of its necessity;
and every where plainly uses the phrase in that sense, for absolute and peremptory, in oppos-
ition to doubtfulness; continually insinuating, that this is what I professedly insist on.
Whereas every act of the judgment whatsoever, is a positive judgment in the sense in which
I have fully declared I use it, viz. in opposition to negative; which is no act, but a mere
withholding of the act of the judgment, or forbearing any actual judgment. 383 Mr. W.
himself does abundantly suppose, that there must be a positive judgment in this sense. He
grants the very thing, though he rejects the term. For he holds, there must be such a visibility
as makes persons to appear to be real saints, (p. 5. b.)—He allows, that the moral image of
God or Christ must appear, or be supposed to be in them, as the ground and reason of our
charity; and that there must be some apprehension, some judgment of mind, of the saintship
of persons, for its foundation, (p. 68. c. d. e. and 69. a. 71. d.)—That they must have such a
character appearing in them. (p. 55. e.)—That there must be a judgment founded on moral
evidence of gospel-holiness, (p. 139. d.)
383 Mr. John Glass. in his Observes upon the original Constitution of the Christian Church, (p. 55, 5b.) says
as follows. “You seem to have a great prejudice of what you call positive evidences, and judging upon them in
the admission of church-members. And I am at some loss to understand what you mean by them, though I have
heard the expression frequently, among people of your opinion, used to express some very ill thing. If you mean
by positive evidences, infallible evidences of a thing that none but God infallibly knows, and can assure a man’s
own conscience of, with respect to a man himself: I think it would be a very great evil for a man to require such
evidence to found his judgment of charity, concerning another man’s faith and holiness, or concerning his being
an object of brotherly love. And I think, he is bound by the law of Christ to form his judgment in this matter
upon less evidence. But if you mean positive evidence in opposition to negative, which is no evidence, I must
own, I know not how to form a judgment of charity without some positive evidence. And is not a credible pro-
fession something positive?—Is not a credible profession of the faith, love, and hope that is in Christ, or of
Christianity, a positive evidence of a man’s being an object of brotherly love, which evidence ought to be the
ground of my judgment of charity concerning him, that he is a Christian, a believer in Christ, a brother for
whom Christ died? If it be otherwise, and if there be no evidence upon which I can charitably judge, that a man
is a brother for whom Christ died? If it be otherwise, and if there be no evidence upon which I can charitably
judge, that a man is a brother for whom Christ died. Then tell me, how I can evidence my love to Jesus Christ,
in the labour of love towards my brother, whom I have seen; and my love to God, in my love to them that are
begotten of him.”
1906
SECTION II. Degrees of evidence.