O. All the paths of your propositions lead to the same
meeting-point, and it is with you as with the frightened
deer—while you fly from the feathers fluttering in the wind, you
become entangled in the strongest of nets. For seeing that a man,
baptized in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost,
becomes a temple of the Lord, and that while the old abode is destroyed
a new shrine is built for the Trinity, how can you say that sins can be
remitted among the Arians without the coming of the Holy Ghost? How is
a soul purged from its former stains which has not the Holy Ghost? For
it is not mere water which washes the soul, but it is itself first
purified by the Spirit that it may be able to spiritually wash the
souls of men. Gen. i. 2.“The
Spirit of the Lord,” says Moses, “moved upon the face of
the waters,” from which it appears that there is no baptism
without the Holy Ghost. Bethesda, the pool in Judea, could not cure the
limbs of those who suffered from bodily weakness without the advent of
an angel, John v. 2 sq. and do you venture to bring me a
soul washed with simple water, as though it had just come from the
bath? Our Lord Jesus Christ Himself, of whom it is less correct to say
that He was cleansed by washing than that by the washing of Himself He
cleansed all waters, no sooner raised His head from the stream than He
received the Holy Ghost. Not that He ever was without the Holy Ghost,
inasmuch as He was born in the flesh through the Holy Ghost; but in
order to prove that to be the true baptism by which the Holy Ghost
comes. So then if an Arian cannot give the Holy Spirit, he cannot even
baptize, because there is no baptism of the Church without the Holy
Spirit. And you, when you receive a person baptized by an Arian and afterwards invoke the Holy Ghost,
ought either to baptize him, because without the Holy Ghost he could
not be baptized, or, if he was baptized in the Spirit, you must not
invoke the Holy Ghost for your convert who received Him at the time of
baptism.