ences, there was also some bitterness arising from mortified pride, because they had not
themselves ordained Cæcilianus bishop of Carthage.
18. When Cæcilianus knew that these men had assembled, not as impartial judges, but
hostile and perverted through all these things, was it possible that either he should consent,
or the people over whom he presided should allow him, to leave the church and go into a
282
private dwelling, where he was not to be tried fairly by his peers, but to be slain by a small
faction, urged on by a woman’s spite, especially when he saw that his case might have an
unbiassed and equitable hearing before the Church beyond the sea, which was uninfluenced
by private enmities on either side in the dispute? If his adversaries declined pleading before
that tribunal, they would thereby cut themselves off from that communion with the whole
world which innocence enjoys. And if they attempted there to bring a charge against him,
then he would compear for himself, and defend his innocence against all their plots, as you
have learned that he afterwards did, when they, already guilty of schism, and stained with
the atrocious crime of having actually reared their rival altar, applied—but too late—for the
decision of the Church beyond the sea. For this they would have done at first, if their cause
had been supported by truth; but their policy was to come to the trial after false rumours
had gained strength by lapse of time, and public report of old standing, so to speak, had
prejudged the case; or, which seems more likely, having first condemned Cæcilianus as they
pleased, they relied for safety upon their number, and did not dare to open the discussion
of so bad a case before other judges, by whom, as they were not influenced by bribery, the
truth might be discovered.
Chap. VII.
19. But when they actually found that the communion of the whole world with Cæcili-
anus continued as before, and that letters of communion from churches beyond the sea
were sent to him, and not to the man whom they had flagitiously ordained, they became
ashamed of being always silent; for it might be objected to them: Why did they suffer the
Church in so many countries to go on in ignorance, communicating with men that were
condemned; and especially why did they cut themselves off from communion with the whole
world, against which they had no charge to make, by their bearing in silence the exclusion
from that communion of the bishop whom they had ordained in Carthage? They chose,
therefore, as it is reported, to bring their dispute with Cæcilianus before the foreign churches,
in order to secure one of two things, either of which they were prepared to accept: if, on the
one hand, by any amount of craft, they succeeded in making good the false accusation, they
would abundantly satisfy their lust of revenge; if, however, they failed, they might remain
as stubborn as before, but would now have, as it were, some excuse for it, in alleging that
they had suffered at the hands of an unjust tribunal,—the common outcry of all worthless
litigants, though they have been defeated by the clearest light of truth,—as if it might not
have been said, and most justly said, to them: “Well, let us suppose that those bishops who
640
To Glorius, Eleusius, etc.