foolish than to say, as some do, that in the bread and wine we worship Ceres and Bacchus.
I refer to this now, to show where you got your silly idea that our fathers kept the Sabbath
in honor of Saturn. For as there is no connection with the worship of the Pagan deities
Ceres and Bacchus in our observance of the sacrament of the bread and wine, which you
approve so highly that you wish to resemble us in it, so there was no subjection to Saturn
in the case of our fathers, who observed the rest of the Sabbath in a manner suitable to
prophetic times.
14. You might have found a resemblance in your religion to that of the Pagans as regards
Hyle [matter], which the Pagans often speak of. You, on the contrary, maintain that you
are directly opposed to them in your belief in the evil principle which your teacher in theology
calls Hyle. But here you only show your ignorance, and, with an affectation of learning,
use this word without knowing what it means. The Greeks, when speaking of nature, give
the name Hyle to the subject-matter of things, which has no form of its own, but admits of
all bodily forms, and is known only through these changeable phenomena, not being itself
an object of sensation or perception. Some Gentiles, indeed, erroneously make this matter
co-eternal with God, as not being derived from Him, though the bodily forms are. In this
manifest error you resemble the Pagans, for you hold that Hyle has a principle of its own,
and does not come from God. It is only ignorance that leads you to deny this resemblance.
In saying that Hyle has no form of its own, and can take its forms only from God, the Pagans
come near to the truth which we believe in contradistinction from your errors. Not knowing
what Hyle or the subject-matter of things is, you make it the race of darkness, in which you
place not only innumerable bodily forms of five different kinds, but also a formative mind.
Such, indeed, is your ignorance or insanity, that you call this mind Hyle, and make it give
forms instead of taking them. If there were such a formative mind as you speak of, and
bodily elements capable of form, the word Hyle would properly be applicable to the bodily
elements, which would be the matter to be formed by the mind, which you make the principle
of evil. Even this would not be a quite accurate use of the word Hyle, which has no form
of any kind; whereas these elements, although capable of new forms, have already the form
of elements, and belong to different kinds. Still this use of the word would not be so much
amiss, notwithstanding your ignorance; for it would thus be applied, as it properly is, to
that which takes form, and not to that which gives it. Even here, however, your folly and
impiety would appear in tracing so much that is good to the evil principle, from your not
knowing that all natures of every kind, all forms in their proportion, and all weights in their
order, can come only from the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. As it is, you know
neither what Hyle is, nor what evil is. Would that I could persuade you to refrain from
misleading people still more ignorant than yourselves!
15. Every one must see the folly of your boasting of superiority to the Pagans because
they use altars and temples, images and sacrifices and incense, in the worship of God, which
442
Faustus repels the charge of sun-worship, and maintains that while the Manichæans…