The
universal testimony of antiquity assigns John’s later life to
Ephesus: e.g. Irenæus, Adv. Hær. III. 1. 1 and 3. 4,
etc.; Clement of Alex., Quis Dives Salvetur, c. 42 (quoted by
Eusebius, chap. 23, below); Polycrates in his Epistle to Victor (quoted
by Eusebius in chap. 31, below, and in Bk. V. chap. 24); and many
others. The testimony of Irenæus is especially weighty, for the
series: Irenæus, the pupil of Polycarp, the pupil of John, forms a
complete chain such as we have in no other case. Such testimony, when
its force is broken by no adverse tradition, ought to be sufficient to
establish John’s residence in Ephesus beyond the shadow of a
doubt, but it has been denied by many of the critics who reject the
Johannine authorship of the fourth Gospel (e.g. Keim, Holtzmann, the
author of Supernat. Religion, and others), though the denial is
much less positive now than it was a few years ago. The chief arguments
urged against the residence of John in Ephesus are two, both a
silentio: first, Clement in his first Epistle to the Corinthians
speaks of the apostles in such a way as to seem to imply that they were
all dead; secondly, in the Ignatian Epistles, Paul is mentioned, but
not John, which is certainly very remarkable, as one is addressed to
Ephesus itself. In reply it may be said that such an interpretation of
Clement’s words is not necessary, and that the omission of John
in the epistles of Ignatius becomes perfectly natural if the Epistles
are thrown into the time of Hadrian or into the latter part of
Trajan’s reign, as they ought to be (cf. chap. 36, note 4). In
the face of the strong testimony for John’s Ephesian residence
these two objections must be overruled. The traditional view is
defended by all conservative critics as well as by the majority even of
those who deny the Johannine authorship of the fourth Gospel (cf.
especially Hilgenfeld in his Einleitung, and Weizsäcker in
his Apostaliches Zeitalter). The silence of Paul’s
epistles and of the Acts proves that John cannot have gone to Ephesus
until after Paul had permanently left there, and this we should
naturally expect to be the case. Upon the time of John’s
banishment to Patmos, see Bk. III. chap. 18, note 1. Tradition reports
that he lived until the reign of Trajan (98–117). Cf.
Irenæus, II. 22. 5 and III. 3. 4.