In one point the learned scholiast just quoted has most
seriously understated his case. He says that the wording of the
canon shews “that the Nicene fathers entertained no doubt that
the faithful in the holy Communion truly received ‘the body of
Christ.’” Now this statement is of course true
because it is included in what the canon says, but the doctrinal
statement which is necessarily contained in the canon is that
“the body of Christ is given” by the minister to the
faithful. This doctrine is believed by all Catholics and by
Lutherans, but is denied by all other Protestants; those Calvinists who
kept most nearly to the ordinary Catholic phraseology only admitting
that “the sacrament of the Body of Christ” was given in the
supper by the minister, while “the body of Christ,” they
taught, was present only in the soul of the worthy communicant (and in
no way connected with the form of bread, which was but the divinely
appointed sign and assurance of the heavenly gift), and therefore could
not be “given” by the priest. Cf. Art. xxviij. of the
“Articles of Religion” of the Church of England, which
declares that “The Body of Christ is given, taken, and eaten in
the Supper,” etc.