Heraclius then published the letter, which
reflected great disgrace upon the writer. For whereas, when the great
Hosius wrote to Constantius, he had been unable to make out any
plausible pretext for his change of conduct, he now invented an excuse
much more discreditable to himself and his advisers. He said,
‘From regard to the affection I entertained towards my brother of
divine and pious memory, I endured for a time the coming of Athanasius
among you.’ This proves that he has both broken his promise, and
behaved ungratefully to his brother after his death. He then declares
him to be, as indeed he is, ‘deserving of divine and pious
remembrance;’ yet as regards a command of his, or to use his own
language, the ‘affection’ he bore him, even though he
complied merely ‘for the sake’ of the blessed Constans, he
ought to deal fairly by his brother, and make himself heir to his
sentiments as well as to the Empire. But, although, when seeking to
obtain his just rights, he deposed Vetranio, with the question,
‘To whom does the inheritance belong after a brother’s
death [a.d. 350, cf. Gibbon Hist. ch.
xviii. vol. ii. p. 378.]?’ yet for the sake of the accursed
heresy of the enemies of Christ, he disregards the claims of justice,
and behaves undutifully towards his brethren. Nay, for the sake of this
heresy, he would not consent to observe even his father’s wishes
without infringement; but, in what he may gratify these impious men, he
pretends to adopt his intention, while in order to distress the others,
he cares not to shew the reverence which is due unto a father. For in
consequence of the calumnies of Eusebius and his fellows, his father
sent the Bishop for a time into Gaul to avoid the cruelty of his
persecutors (this was shewn by the blessed Constantine, the brother of
the former, after their father’s death, as appears by his
letters Apol. Ar. 87.), but he would not be persuaded by
Eusebius and his fellows to send the person whom they desired for a
Bishop, but prevented the accomplishment of their wishes, and put a
stop to their attempts with severe threats.