It is, then, clear that the question raised by the wide
circulation of the discourses of Nestorius as archbishop of
Constantinople was not verbal, but vital. Much of his language
was irrelevant, and indicated some confusedness of thought: much
would, of itself, admit of an orthodox construction; in one of the
latest of his sermons, which Garnier dates on Sunday, December 14, 430,
he grants that “Theotocos” might be used as signifying that
“the temple which was formed in Mary by the Holy Spirit was
united to the Godhead;” but it was impossible not to ask whether
by “the temple” he meant the body of Jesus, or Jesus
himself regarded as a human individual existing ἰδίᾳ, ἰδικῶς,
ἀνὰ μέρος—as
Cyril represents his theory—and whether by “union” he
meant more than a close alliance, ejusdem generis, in the last
analysis, with the relation between God and every saint, or, indeed,
every Christian in true moral fellowship with him—an alliance
which would amount, in Cyril’s phrase, to no more than a
“relative union,” and would reduce the Saviour to a
“Theophoros,” the title claimed of old by one of his chief
martyrs. And the real identity of Nestorius’s view with
that of Theodore [of Mopsuestia] was but too plainly exhibited by such
statements as occur in some of the extracts preserved in Cyril’s
treatise Against Nestorius—to the effect that Christ was
one with the Word by participation in dignity; that “the
man” was partaker of Divine power, and in that sense not mere
man; that he was adored together with the Word; and that “My Lord
and my God” was a doxology to the Father; and above all, by the
words spoken at Ephesus, “I can never allow that a child of three
months old was God.”