The dates assigned to Victor’s episcopate by the ancient
authorities vary greatly. Eusebius here puts his accession in the tenth
year of Commodus (i.e. 189 a.d.), and this is
accepted by Lipsius as the correct date. Jerome’s version of the
Chron. puts his accession in the reign of Pertinax, or the first
year of Septimius Severus (i.e. 193), while the Armenian version puts
it in the seventh year of Commodus (186). Eusebius, in his
History, does not state directly the duration of his episcopate,
but in chap. 28 he says that Zephyrinus succeded him about the ninth
year of Severus, i.e. according to his erroneous reckoning (see Bk. VI.
chap. 21, note 3) about 200, which would give Victor an episcopate of
about eleven years. Jerome, in his version of the Chron. and in
his de vir. ill., assigns him ten years; the Armenian version of
the Chron. twelve years. The Liberian Catalogue makes his
episcopate something over nine years long; the Felician Catalogue
something over ten. Lipsius, considering Victor in connection with his
successors, concludes that he held office between nine and ten years,
and therefore gives as his dates 189–198 or 199 (see p. 172 sq.).
According to an anonymous writer quoted in chap. 28, Victor
excommunicated Theodotus of Byzantium for teaching that Christ was a
mere man. He is best known, however, on account of his action in
connection with the great Quartodeciman controversy (see chap. 24).
Jerome, in his version of the Chron., says of him cujus
mediocria de religione extant volumina, and in his de vir.
ill. chap. 34, he tells us that he wrote upon the passover, and
also some other works (super quæstione Paschæ, et alia
quædam scribens opuscula). Harnack believes that he has
discovered one of these works (all of which have been supposed lost) in
the Pseudo-Cyprianic de Aleatoribus. In his Texte und
Unters. Bd. V. Heft 1, he has discussed the subject in a very
learned and ingenious manner. The theory has much to commend it, but
there are difficulties in its way which have not yet been removed; and
I am inclined to think it a product of the first half of the third
century, rather than of the last quarter of the second (see the
writer’s review of Harnack’s discussion in the
Presbyterian Review, Jan., 1889, p. 143 sqq.).