To my Lord, beloved brother, and most-longed-for
fellow-minister Epictetus Of
Epictetus, bishop of Corinth, nothing else is known. This letter
reflects the uncertainty, which attended the victory of the Nicene
Creed, as to the relation of the Historical Christ to the Eternal Son.
The questions raised at Corinth were those which troubled the Eastern
Church generally, and which came to a head in the system of
Apollinarius, whose distinctive tenet, however, is not mentioned in
this letter. Persons anxious to place the Nicene doctrine in
intelligible connection with the matter of the Gospel Narrative had
debated the question before Epictetus, and with deference to his
ruling. Their tentative solutions (§2 infr.) fall into two
classes, both of which, in attempting to solve the problem, proceed
upon the assumption incidentally combated by Athan., that the Manhood
of Christ was a Hypostasis or Person, which if invested with Divine
attributes, would introduce a fourth hypostatic entity into the
Trinity. To avoid this, one class identified the Logos and the
῎Ανθρωπος, either by assuming that the Logos was changed into flesh,
or that the flesh was itself non-natural and of the Divine Essence. The
other class excluded the Man Jesus from the Trinity, explaining His
relation to God on the lines of Photinus or the later Nestorians. Both
alternatives are already glanced at (supr. p. 485) by the
Council of 362. In the present case, both classes of suggestions seem
to have been made tentatively and bona fide (§12). The
letter must have been written before the two books against
Apollinarianism, which (if genuine) fall about 372. Its more exact date
depends on the identification of the Councils referred to in §1
(νῦν
γενομένων), and is therefore very doubtful. At any rate
Apollinarianism proper is not alluded to, and Apollinarius is said to
have expressed to Serapion of Thmuis his high opinion of our Letter
(see Letter 54, note 1). It was much quoted in the
Christological controversies of the next 80 years, e.g. by the Councils
of Ephesus and Chalcedon, by Theodoret, Cyril, and Leo the Great (see
Migne xxvi. 1050; Bright, Later Treatises, pp. 43 sq.,
and D.C.B. s.v. Epictetus and Apollinaris the younger)., Athanasius
greeting in the Lord. I thought that all vain talk of all heretics,
many as they may be, had been stopped by the Synod which was held at
Nicæa. For the Faith there confessed by the Fathers according to
the divine Scriptures is enough by itself at once to overthrow all
impiety, and to establish the religious belief in Christ. For this
reason at the present time, at the assembling of diverse synods, both
in Gaul and Spain, and great Rome Are
these those referred to in the letter to Ruf., and held a.d. 362–3, or are they to be identified with one or
other of those held under Damasus (see Introd. to ad
Afros.)?, all who came
together, as though moved by one spirit, unanimously anathematised
those who still were secretly holding with Arius, namely Auxentius of
Milan, Ursacius, Valens, and Gaius of Pannonia. And they wrote
everywhere, that, whereas the above-said were devising the names of
synods to cite on their side, no synod should be cited in the Catholic
Church save only that which was held at Nicæa, which was a
monument of victory over all heresy, but especially the Arian, which
was the main reason of the synod assembling when it did. How then,
after all this, are some attempting to raise doubts or questions? If
they belong to the Arians, this is not to be wondered at, that they
find fault with what was drawn up against themselves, just as the
Gentiles when they hear that ‘the idols of the heathen are silver
and gold, the work of men’s hands Ps. cxv. 4.,’ think the doctrine of the divine
Cross folly. But if those who desire to reopen everything by raising
questions belong to those who think they believe aright, and love what
the fathers have declared, they are simply doing what the prophet
describes, giving their neighbour turbid confusion to drink Hab. ii. 15, LXX., and fighting about words to no good
purpose, save to the subversion of the simple.