226 GOSPEL ACCORDING TO CHAP. VI.
tobelieve,they stillaskedformiracleswhereby to believe;
They saidthereforeuntoHim, What signshelvest Thou then,
thatwe may seeand believeThee? What dostThou work?
CHRYS. Nothing can be more unreasonablethantheirask-
ingforanothermiracle,asifnone had been givenalready.
And theydo not evenleavethe choiceofthemiracletoour
Lord ; but would obligeHim to givethem justthatsign,
which was giventotheirfathers: Our fathersdideatmanna
in thedesert.ALCUIN. And to exaltthe miracleof the
manna,theyquotethePsalm,As itiswritten,He gavethem
breadfrom heaventoeat. CHRYS. Whereas many miracles
wereperformedin Egypt,at theliedSea,and inthedesert,
they remembered thisone the bestof any. Such is the
forceofappetite.They do not mention thismiracleas the
work eitherof God, or of Moses,in orderto avoidraising
Him on the one hand to an equalitywith God, or lowering
Him on the otherby a comparisonwith Moses ; but they
take a middle ground, only saying,Our fathersdid eat
Aug.Tr. manna in thedesert.AUG. Or thus; Our Lord setsHim-xxv.s.12.selfaooveMoses,who did notdareto say thathe gave the
meat which perishethnot. The multitudethereforeremem
beringwhat Moses had done,and wishingforsome greater
miracle,say,as it were,Thou promisestthe meat which
perishethnot,and doestnot works equalto thoseMoses
did. He gaveus notbarleyloaves,but manna from heaven.
Chrys. CHRYS. Our Lord might have replied,that He had done
^"'i miraclesgreaterthan Moses : butitwas not the time for
such a declaration.One thing He desired,viz.to bring
them totastethe spiritualmeat : then Jesussaiduntothem,
Verily,verily,I sayuntoyou,Mosesgaveyou notthatbread
fromheaven; but My Fathergivethyou thetruebreadfrom
heaven. Did not themanna come from heaven? True,but
in what sensedid it? The same in which the birdsare
called,the birdsof heavenk; and justas itissaidin the
Pa.17. Psalm,The Lord thunderedoutof heaven. He callsitthe
truebread,not becausethemiracleofthe manna was false,
but becauseitwas the figure,notthereality.He doesnot
saytoo,Moses gaveityou not,but I : but He putsGod for
An*.Tr. Moses,Himselfforthe manna. AUG. As ifHe said,That
xxv. 31.
* Volucrescceli,Vulgatetranslationoffowlsoftheair.