Chapter 16.—Concerning the Philosophers Who Think that the Separation of Soul and
Body is Not Penal, Though Plato Represents the Supreme Deity as Promising to the Inferior
Gods that They Shall Never Be Dismissed from Their Bodies.
But the philosophers against whom we are defending the city of God, that is, His Church
seem to themselves to have good cause to deride us, because we say that the separation of
the soul from the body is to be held as part of man’s punishment. For they suppose that the
blessedness of the soul then only is complete, when it is quite denuded of the body, and re-
turns to God a pure and simple, and, as it were, naked soul. On this point, if I should find
nothing in their own literature to refute this opinion, I should be forced laboriously to
demonstrate that it is not the body, but the corruptibility of the body, which is a burden to
the soul. Hence that sentence of Scripture we quoted in a foregoing book, “For the corruptible
body presseth down the soul.”598 The word corruptible is added to show that the soul is
burdened, not by any body whatsoever, but by the body such as it has become in consequence
of sin. And even though the word had not been added, we could understand nothing else.
But when Plato most expressly declares that the gods who are made by the Supreme have
immortal bodies, and when he introduces their Maker himself, promising them as a great
boon that they should abide in their bodies eternally, and never by any death be loosed from
them, why do these adversaries of ours, for the sake of troubling the Christian faith, feign
to be ignorant of what they quite well know, and even prefer to contradict themselves rather
than lose an opportunity of contradicting us? Here are Plato’s words, as Cicero has translated
them,599 in which he introduces the Supreme addressing the gods He had made, and saying,
“Ye who are sprung from a divine stock, consider of what works I am the parent and author.
These (your bodies) are indestructible so long as I will it; although all that is composed can
be destroyed. But it is wicked to dissolve what reason has compacted. But, seeing that ye
have been born, ye cannot indeed be immortal and indestructible; yet ye shall by no means
be destroyed, nor shall any fates consign you to death, and prove superior to my will, which
is a stronger assurance of your perpetuity than those bodies to which ye were joined when
ye were born.” Plato, you see, says that the gods are both mortal by the connection of the
body and soul, and yet are rendered immortal by the will and decree of their Maker. If,
therefore, it is a punishment to the soul to be connected with any body whatever, why does
God address them as if they were afraid of death, that is, of the separation, of soul and body?
Why does He seek to reassure them by promising them immortality, not in virtue of their
nature, which is composite and not simple, but by virtue of His invincible will, whereby He
can effect that neither things born die, nor things compounded be dissolved, but preserved
eternally?
598 Wisdom ix. 15.
599 A translation of part of the Timæus, given in a little book of Cicero’s, De Universo.
Concerning the Philosophers Who Think that the Separation of Soul and Body is Not Penal, Though Plato Represents the Supreme Deity as Promising to the Inferior Gods that They Shall Never Be Dismissed from Their Bodies.
576
Concerning the Philosophers Who Think that the Separation of Soul and Body…