CHAP. IV.] CHRISTIAN REjuIGION. 599
might be clean, (9) he is not exhorting them to make a satis-
faction, but only teaching them what kind of purity obtains
the Divine approbation. But of this expression we have treated
lU another work.*
XXXVII. With respect to the passage of Luke, (r) no one,
who has read with a sound judgment the parable the Lord
there proposes, will enter into any controversy with us ;,()n-
cerning it. The Pharisee thought within himself, that the
Lord did not know the woman, whom he had so easily admit-
ted to his presence. For he imagined that Christ would not
have admitted her, if he had known what kind of a sinner she
was. And thence he inferred that Christ, who was capable of
being so deceived, was not a prophet. To show that she was
not a sinner, her sins having already been forgiven, the Lord
proposed this parable : " There was a certain creditor, which
had two debtors ; the one owed five hundred pence, and the
other fifty. He frankly forgave them both. Which of them
will love him most ? " The Pharisee answered, "He to
whom he forgave most." The Lord rejoins, Hence know that
" this woman's sins, which are many, are forgiven ; for she
loved much." In these words, you see, he makes her love, not
the cause of the remission of her sins, but the proof of it. For
they are taken from a comparison of that debtor to whom five
hundred pence had been forgiven, of whom it is said, not that
his debt was forgiven, because he had loved much, but that he
loved much because his debt had been forgiven. And this
similitude may be applied to the case of the woman in the fol-
lowing manner : " You suppose this woman to be a sinner ; but
you ought to know that she is not such, since her sins are
forgiven her. And her love ought to convince you of the re-
mission of her sins, by the grateful return she makes for this
blessing." It is an argumentum a posteriori, by which any
thing is proved from its consequences. By what means she
obtained renwssion of sins, the Lord plainly declares : " Thy
faith," says he, " hath saved thee." ..JBy.,iaith, therefore W-jw
obtain remission, by love we give thanks and^declare tl^^^^^
ness of the Lorg,v^,^..-..o..,L»«
XXXVIII, To those things which frequently occur in the
works of the fathers concerning satisfaction, I pay little re-
gard. I see, indeed, that some of them, or, to speak plainly,
almost all whose writings are extant, have either erred on this
point, or expressed themselves too harshly. But I shall not
acRiul that thev were so ignorant and inexperienced, as to write
those thing- in the sense in which they are understood by the
modern advocates for satisfaction. Chrysostom somewhere
(q) Luke XI 39—41. * In Harm. Evang. (r) Luke vii. 39.