This letter was
addressed by St. Athanasius to the bishops of his Province after his
expulsion by Syrianus (Feb. 8, 356), and when the nomination of George
the contractor to the Alexandrian See was already known (§7). But
no details of the persecution of the orthodox in Egypt had reached
Athanasius when he wrote, in fact he mentions it as only beginning
(§5). This points to about the Easter of 356; see Prolegg. ch. ii.
§8 (1). The tract thus opens the series of anti-Arian works
composed during the ‘third exile.’ It has indeed been
inferred (by Baronius and others) from §22 that the letter was
written thirty-six years after the Nicene Synod, i.e. in 361. But it
was certainly written before the arrival of George, and in the passage
referred to it is the first condemnation of Arius by Alexander, and not
the Council of Nicæa, that is placed thirty-six years ago. The
primary purpose of the letter is to warn the bishops against a
formulary which was on the point of being circulated for their
acceptance on pain of banishment (§5). The creed in question
cannot now be identified,—but it was very possibly the Sirmian
Creed of 351 (de Synod. 27), not formally Arian, but evading the
Nicene test (§10). He begins, accordingly, after a general warning
(1–4) against being imposed upon by mere words, and a statement
(5) of the tactics of his opponents, by urging the bishops to hold to
the faith of Nicæa, in contrast to the shifting professions of its
opponents (6–8), and to be satisfied with nothing short of an
explicit repudiation of Arianism (9–11). In the Second Part of
the Letter he turns to doctrine. He states (12) the original Arian
position, and confronts it (13) with passages from Scripture. He
challenges the Arians (14) to state any clear belief as to the nature
of the Word, which shall reconcile their premises with the language of
Holy Writ (15, 16). He explains Prov. viii. 22 of the Incarnation, and taxes the Arians
with denying this truth, like the heathen (17). He next taxes them with
dissimulation, especially Arius in his profession to Constantine (18);
he describes the death of Arius, and presses the charge of complicity
with a man already judged by God (19). He urges the bishops (20, 21) to
steadfastness and confessorship, reprobates the coalition of Meletians
(22) and Arians, and finally expresses the conviction (23) that the
Emperor Constantius will put an end to these outrages when informed of
the true facts of the case.