But the Eusebians were not limited to technical
complaints. They had stirring accounts to give of the disorders which
the return of Athanasius had excited, of the ruthless severity with
which they had been put down by the prefect, who was, it was probably
added, a mere tool in the hands of the bishop. Accordingly in the
course of 338 the subservient Theodorus was recalled, and Philagrius
the Cappadocian, who had governed with immense The
ordinary time for the entry of the Prefect upon his duties seems to
have been about the end of the Egyptian Year (end of August).
Accordingly the prefectures and years in Fest. Ind. roughly
correspond: Philagrius was already Prefect when the Mareotic Commission
arrived (Aug. 335). According to the headings to the Festal Letters
vi., vii., he had superseded Paternus in 334: either the Index or the
headings are mistaken. For the popularity of Philagrius, see Greg. Naz.
Orat. xxi. 28, who mentions that his reappointment was due to
the request of a deputation from Alex. (this must have come from the
Arians!) and that the rejoicings which welcomed his return exceeded any
that could have greeted the Emperor, and nearly equalled those
which had welcomed the return of Athanasius himself. But Gregory is a
rhetorician; see p. 138, and Tillem. viii. 664.
popularity in 335–337 (Fest. Ind. and p. 107 sq.),
was sent to fill the office a second time. This was regarded at
Alexandria as an Arian triumph (see p. 527, note 2). His arrival did
not tend to allay the disorders. Old charges against Athanasius were
raked up, and a new one added, namely that of embezzlement of the corn
appropriated to the support of widows by the imperial bounty. The
Emperor appears to have sent a letter of complaint to Athanasius (p.
273), but to have paid little attention to his defence. The Eusebians
now ventured to send a bishop of their own to Alexandria in the person
of Pistus, one of the original Arian presbyters, who was consecrated by
the implacable Secundus. The date of this proceeding is obscure,
probably it was conducted in an irregular manner, so as to render it
possible to ignore it altogether if, as proved to be the case, a
stronger candidate should be necessary. First, however, it was
necessary to try the temper of the West. A deputation consisting of a
presbyter Macarius and two deacons, Martyrius and Hesychius, was sent
to Julius, bishop of Rome, to lay before him the enormities of
Athanasius, Marcellus, Paul, Asclepas and the rest, and to urge the superior title of Pistus to the
recognition of the Church. But upon hearing of this Athanasius summoned
the Egyptian Episcopate together (winter 338–339), and composed a
circular letter (pp. 101–110) dealing fully with the charges
against him, especially with regard to the manner of his election and
the irregularity of his return a year before. Two presbyters carried
the letter in haste to Rome, and enlightened the Church there as to the
antecedents of Pistus. Next day it was announced that Macarius,
‘in spite of a bodily ailment,’ had decamped in the night.
The deacons however remained, and requested Julius to call a council,
undertaking that if Athanasius and the Eusebians were confronted all
the charges brought by the latter should be made good. This proposal
seemed unobjectionable, and Julius wrote inviting all parties to a
council at Rome, or some other place to be agreed upon (p. 272); his
messengers to the Eusebians were the Roman presbyters Elpidius and
Philoxenus It is
possible, however, that these carried a second letter,
after the arrival of Ath. See pp. 110, 273., (p. 111). The council was fixed for the
following summer (so it would seem); but no reply was received from the
Eusebians, who kept the presbyters in the East until the following
January, when they at length started for Rome bearing a querulous and
somewhat shifty reply (answered by Julius, p. 111, sqq.). But
before the invitation had reached the Eusebians they had assembled at
Antioch, where Constantius was in residence for the winter (laws dated
Dec. 27; the court thereon January ? p. 92), repeated the deposition of
Athanasius, and appointed Gregory, a Cappadocian, to succeed him. It
had become clear that Pistus was a bad candidate; perhaps no formal
synod could be induced to commit themselves to a man excommunicated at
Nicæa and consecrated by Secundus. At any rate they tried to find
an unexceptionable nominee. But their first, Eusebius, afterwards
bishop of Emesa, refused the post, and so they came to Gregory Gregory
shewed his Arianism by employing Ammon as his secretary, see p. 96. The
curious parallelism between Gregory and George (infr.
§8),—the names differing (in Latin) by a single letter only,
both Arians, both Cappadocians, both intruded bishops of Alexandria,
both arriving from court, both arriving in Lent, both exercising
violence, both charged by Ath. with the storming of churches, with
similar scenes of desecration, maltreatment of virgins, &c., in
either case,—is one of the strangest examples of history
repeating itself within a few years. What wonder that the fifth-century
historians confuse the two still further together, and that they still
find followers? The most important point of confusion is the alleged
murder of Gregory (due to Theodoret), who really died a natural death.
It is none too soon for this time-honoured blunder to do the like. On
the inveterate tendency of Georges and Gregories to coalesce, and
exchange names in transcription (to say nothing of modern typography),
see D.C.B. ii. pp. 640–650, 778 sq., 798 sq.,
passim., a former student of Alexandria, and under
personal obligations to its bishop (Greg. Naz. Or. xxi. 15).