to help forward the delusions of Satan. I am apt to believe the grounds upon which you
proceed, in the whole paragraph I have mentioned, is, that you have with you real Antino-
mians, who teach things about faith and believing, subversive of new obedience and gospel
holiness, and inconsistent with the scripture doctrines concerning them. But as we have
few, if any such at all, (I believe I might say more,) in this country, and at the same time
have numbers who would have the most accurate and judicious evangelical preachers to
insist a great deal more upon doing, and less upon believing, Mark x. 17-23. for what reasons
you will perceive, I am afraid your words will be misrepresented by them, and a sense put
upon your expressions, which you were far from intending. I expect a mighty clamour by
the Seceders, if the book shall fall into their hands. All I shall say about what is expressed
by you, page 78, line 32, &c. is, that I have frequently heard it taught by those accounted the
most orthodox, that the believer was bound to trust in the Lord, in the very worst frame he
could be in, and that the exercise of faith was the way to be delivered from darkness, deadness,
backsliding, &c. It is impossible one should err, who follows the course prescribed by the
Lord in his word. I suppose no person is bound or allowed to defer believing one single
moment, because he finds himself in a bad situation, because the Spirit breathes not on him,
or he finds not actual influence from heaven communicated to him at that season, rendering
him capable or meet for it; for this reason, that not our ability or fitness, but the Lord’s
command, is the rule of duty, &c. It merits consideration, whether the believer should ever
doubt of his state, on any account whatever; because doubting, as opposed to believing, is
absolutely sinful. I know the opposite has been prescribed, when the saint is plunged in
prevailing iniquity; but does not doubting strengthen corruption? is not unbelief the leading
sin, as faith is the leading grace?
Page 258, (Note,) you cite as an authority Mr. Stoddard, affirming, ‘One way of sin is
exception enough against men’s salvation, though their temptations be great.’ I well remember
the singularly judicious Dr. Owen somewhere says to this effect, ‘Prevalence of a particular
sin over a person for a considerable time, shows him to be no saint, except when under the
power of a strong temptation.’ I would suppose such texts as Isaiah lxiv. 6. page 65, 3, &c.
warranted the Doctor to assert as he did. It is, I own, no small difficulty to steer the middle
course, betwixt affording hypocrites ground unwarrantably to presume on the one hand,
and wounding the Lord’s dear children on the other; and all the little knowledge of the
Scriptures I would hope the Lord has given me, makes me think Mr. Shepherd, good and
great man as he was, verged not a little to the last extreme, with whom, if I mistake not, Mr.
Stoddard symbolizes in the above assertion; for such as I have mentioned, I apprehend is
the drift and tendency of Mr. Shepherd’s principles. In some instances, daily experience and
observation confirm me still more, that we should be very cautious and modest when assert-
ing on that head, and should take care to go no further in the matter, than we have plain
Scripture to bear us out. The consideration, that indwelling sin sometimes certainly gets
170
CHAPTER XIV. Mistakes extensively prevalent at this time, as to the nature…