Of his first introduction to Alexander a famous
story is told by Rufinus (Hist. Eccl. I. xiv.). The Bishop, on
the anniversary of the martyrdom of his predecessor, Peter, was
expecting some clergy to dinner after service in a house by the sea.
Out of the window, he saw some boys at play on the shore: as he
watched, he saw that they were imitating the sacred rites of the
Church. Thinking at last that they were going too far, he sent some of
his clergy to bring them in. At first his enquiries of the little
fellows produced an alarmed denial. But at length he elicited that one
of them had acted the Bishop and had baptized some of the others in the
character of catechumens. On ascertaining that all details had been
duly observed, he consulted his clergy, and decided that the baptisms
should be treated as valid, and that the boy-bishop and his clergy had
given such plain proof of their vocation that their parents must be
instructed to hand them over to be educated for the sacred profession.
Young Athanasius accordingly, after a further course of elementary
studies, was handed over to the bishop to be brought up, like Samuel,
in the Temple of God. This, adds Sozomen (ii. 17), was the origin of
his subsequent attachment to Alexander as deacon and secretary. The
story is credited by some writers of weight (most recently, by
Archdeacon Farrar), but seems highly improbable. It depends on the
single authority of a writer not famed for historical judgment, and on
the very first anniversary of Peter’s martyrdom, when Alexander
had hardly ascended the episcopal throne, Athanasius was at least
fourteen years old. The probability that the anniversary would have
been other than the first, and the possibility that Athanasius was even
older, coupled with the certainty that his theological study began
before Peter’s martyrdom, compel us to mark the story with at
least a strong note of interrogation. But it may be allowed to confirm
us in the belief that Alexander early singled out the promise of
ability and devotion which marked Athanasius for his right-hand man
long before the crisis which first proved his unique value.