6. You ask me whether you ought to fast on the Sabbath i.e. on
Saturday. and to receive the eucharist daily
according to the custom—as currently reported—of the
churches of Rome and Spain. At this time the
communion was celebrated daily at Constantinople, in Africa, and in
Spain. At Rome it was celebrated on every day of the week except
Saturday (the Sabbath). See Socrates, H. E. v. 22. Both these
points have been treated by the eloquent Hippolytus, A leading Roman
churchman, bishop of Portus, in the early part of the third century,
the rival and enemy of pope Callistus and author of many theological
treatises, one of which—the Refutation of all
Heresies—has recently become famous. and several writers have collected
passages from different authors bearing upon them. The best advice that
I can give you is this. Church-traditions—especially when they do
not run counter to the faith—are to be observed in the form in
which previous generations have handed them down; and the use of one
church is not to be annulled because it is contrary to that of
another. Compare the similar
advice given by Gregory the Great to Augustine of Canterbury (Bede, H.
E. 1. 27). As regards fasting, I wish that we
could practise it without intermission as—according to the Acts
of the Apostles Nothing in the
book of Acts bears out this statement. Fasting at the times mentioned
was forbidden in Jerome’s day.—Paul did
and the believers with him even in the season of Pentecost and on the
Lord’s Day. They are not to be accused of manichæism, for
carnal food ought not to be preferred before spiritual. As regards the
holy eucharist you may receive it at all times Daily if you will
and on fast days as well as on feast days. without qualm of conscience or
disapproval from me. You may listen to the psalmist’s
words:—“O taste and see that the Lord is good;” Ps. xxxiv. 8. you may sing as he does:—“my
heart poureth forth a good word.” Ps. xlv. 1, Vulg.
But do not mistake my meaning. You are not to fast on feast-days,
neither are you to abstain on the week days in Pentecost. i.e. the
period of fifty days between Easterday and Whitsunday. See Letter XLI.
§3. In such matters each province may follow
its own inclinations, and the traditions which have been handed down
should be regarded as apostolic laws.