all Mine are Thine,” He says, “and Thine are Mine967.” What then will the poor creatures
say? Which is more reasonable—that the Son, Who has said, “Thine are Mine, and I am
glorified in them968,” should be glorified in the sovereignty of the Father, or that insult
should be offered to the Father by the degradation involved in the slavery of the Son? For
it is not possible that He Who contains in Himself all that belongs to the Son, and Who is
Himself in the Son, should not also absolutely be in the slavery of the Son, and have slavery
in Himself. Such are the results achieved by Eunomius’ philosophy, whereby he inflicts upon
his Lord the insult of slavery, while he attaches the same degradation to the stainless glory
of the Father.
Let us however return once more to the course of his treatise. What does Eunomius say
concerning the Only-begotten? That He “does not appropriate the dignity,” for he calls the
appellation of “being” a “dignity.” A startling piece of philosophy! Who of all men that have
ever been, whether among Greeks or barbarian sages, who of the men of our own day, who
of the men of all time ever gave “being” the name of “dignity”? For everything that is regarded
as subsisting969 is said, by the common custom of all who use language, to “be”: and from
the word “be” has been formed the term “being.” But now the expression “dignity” is applied
in a new fashion to the idea expressed by “being.” For he says that “the Son, Who is and
lives because of the Father, does not appropriate this dignity,” having no Scripture to support
his statement, and not conducting his statement to so senseless a conclusion by any process
of logical inference, but as if he had taken into his intestines some windy food, he belches
forth his blasphemy in its crude and unmethodized form, like some unsavoury breath. “He
does not appropriate this dignity.” Let us concede the point of “being” being called “dignity.”
What then? does He Who is not appropriate being? “No,” says Eunomius, “because He exists
by reason of the Father.” Do you not then say that He Who does not appropriate being is
not? for “not to appropriate” has the same force as “to be alien from”, and the mutual op-
position of the ideas970 is evident. For that which is “proper” is not “alien,” and that which
is “alien” is not “proper.” He therefore Who does not “appropriate” being is obviously alien
from being: and He Who is alien from being is nonexistent.
But his cogent proof of this absurdity he brings forward in the words, “as the essence
which controls even Him attracts to itself the conception of the Existent.” Let us say nothing
about the awkwardness of the combination here: let us examine his serious meaning. What
argument ever demonstrated this? He superfluously reiterates to us his statement of the
Essence of the Father having sovereignty over the Son. What evangelist is the patron of this
967 S. John xvii. 10.
968 S. John xvii. 10.
969 ἐν ὑποστάσει θεωρούμενον
970 The ideas of “own” implied in “appropriate,” and that of incongruity implied in “alienation.”
437
After this he shows that the Son, who truly is, and is in the bosom of the…