The ecumenical character of this Synod certainly cannot
be proved. Hefele refers to his
having himself treated this matter fully in the Theologischer Quartalschrift of Tübingen,
1852. It is indeed
true that it was the design of Pope Julius, as well as of the two
Emperors, Constantius and Constans, to summon a General Council at
Sardica; but we do not find that any such actually took place:
and the history of the Church points to many like cases, where a synod
was probably intended to be ecumenical, and yet did not attain that
character. In the present case, the Eastern and Western bishops
were indeed summoned, but by far the greater number of the Eastern
bishops were Eusebians, and therefore Semi-Arians, and instead of
acting in a better mind in union with the orthodox, they separated
themselves and formed a cabal of their own at Philippopolis.