Verse 12
assigns the ground of v. 11. “Sin brings penalty and death whether committed
under the Mosaic law or under the ethical law of conscience.” The
first member of the sentence (v.
12)
applies to the Gentiles. They have sinned without the standard and
guidance of positive law; they are, therefore, not brought to the test
of that law’s demands, but to the tests of natural, moral law
(which the apostle will directly describe), and by that test their sins
meet their penalty. Death, as sin’s penalty, is coextensive with
sin, not with the Mosaic law. Sin existed before the Mosaic law
and apart from it; it is imputed to the Gentiles—not, indeed in
the same way and degree (Rom. v. 13)—because
they have a law of conscience. Each class is judged by the standard
which has been given to them. All the terms relating to law here
signify the Mosaic law, which was to Paul the specific statutory
expression of the divine will and the embodiment of moral principles
and duties.—G.B.S.