The Greek reads καὶ τὰ
Μαξιμου περὶ
τοῦ
πολυθρυλήτου
παρὰ τοῖς
αἱρεσιώταις
ζητήματος,
τοῦ πόθεν ἡ
κακία, καὶ
περὶ τοῦ
γενητὴν
ὑπ€ρχειν τὴν
ὕλην. The plural
τὰ (sc. ὑπομνήματα) might lead us to suppose Eusebius refers here to separate
works, were it not for the fact that in his Præp. Evang.
VII. 22 is found a long extract from a work of Maximus On Matter
(περὶ
τῆς ὕλης)
in which the subject of the origin of evil is discussed in connection
with the origin and nature of matter. In that age one could hardly
discuss the origin of evil without at the same time discussing matter,
to which the origin of evil was referred by the great majority of the
ancients. We are to suppose, then, that the work of Maximus bore the
double title given by Eusebius in this chapter. Jerome in his de
vir. ill. chap. 47, says: Maximus…famosam
quæstionem insigni volumine ventilavit, unde malum, et quod
materia a Deo facta sit. As remarked above, a long extract, which
must have been taken from this work, is given by Eusebius in his
Præp. Evang. It appears from this extract that the work was
written in the form of a dialogue between three speakers,—two
inquirers, and one orthodox Christian. The same fragment of
Maximus’ work is found also in the twenty-fourth chapter of the
Philocalia of Origen, and is said by the editors, Gregory and
Basil, to have been copied by them from Eusebius’ work. The
Dialogue on Free Will, ascribed to Methodius (of the early part
of the fourth century), made large use of this work of Maximus; and the
same is to be said of the Pseudo-Origenistic Dialogue against the
Marcionites, though according to Routh (Rel. Sac. II. p. 79)
the latter drew his quotations from Methodius and not directly from
Maximus. The work of Methodius undoubtedly contains much more of
Maximus’ work than is given here by Eusebius; but it is difficult
to ascertain what is his own and what belongs to Maximus, and Routh, in
publishing the fragments of Maximus’ work (ibid. p.
87–107), gives only the extract quoted by Eusebius. In his
Præp. Evang. Eusebius speaks of Maximus as τῆς
χριστοῦ
διατριβὴς
οὐκ ἄσημος
ἀνήρ, but we know no more
about him than has been already indicated. Gallandius suggests that he
may be identical with Maximus, the twenty-sixth bishop of Jerusalem
(see above, chap. 12), who, it is quite probable, lived about this time
(cf. Eusebius’ Chron., year of Abr. 2202). But Eusebius,
neither in this chapter nor in his Præp. Evang., calls
Maximus a bishop, and it seems proper to conclude that he at least did
not know that he was a bishop; and hence Gallandius’ conjecture,
which rests only upon agreement in a very common name, must be
pronounced quite baseless.