Porphyry, one of the most distinguished of the Neo-Platonists,
disciple, biographer, and expounder of Plotinus, was born in 232 or 233
in the Orient (perhaps at Tyre), and at the age of thirty went to Rome,
where he came into connection with Plotinus, and spent a large part of
his life. He was a man of wide and varied learning; and though not an
original thinker, he was a clear and vigorous writer and expounder of
the philosophy of Plotinus. It may be well, at this point, to say a
word about that remarkable school or system of philosophy, of which
Plotinus was the greatest master and Porphyry the chief expounder.
Neo-Platonism was the most prominent phenomenon of the age in the
philosophic world. The object of the Neo-Platonists was both
speculative and practical: on the one side to elaborate an eclectic
system of philosophy which should reconcile Platonism and
Aristotelianism, and at the same time do justice to elements of truth
in other schools of thought; on the other side, to revivify and
strengthen the old paganism by idealizing and purifying it for the sake
of the philosophers, and at the same time by giving it a firmer
philosophic basis than it had hitherto possessed. Neo-Platonism, taken
as a whole, has therefore both a philosophic and a religious motive. It
may be defined in the briefest terms, in its philosophic aspect, as an
eclectic revival of Greek metaphysics (especially
Platonic-Aristotelian), modified by the influence of Oriental
philosophy and of Christianity; in its religious aspect, as an attempt
to restore and regenerate paganism by means of philosophy. In its
earlier and better days, the philosophic element greatly
predominated,—in fact, the religious element may be said to have
been, in large part, a later growth; but gradually the latter came more
and more into the foreground, until, under Jamblichus (d. 330 a.d.), the chief master of the Syrian school,
Neo-Platonism degenerated into a system of religious mysteries, in
which theurgic practices played a prominent part. Under Proclus (d.
485), the great master of the Athenian school, the philosophic element
was again emphasized; but Aristotelianism now gained the predominance,
and the system became a sort of scholastic art, and gradually
degenerated into pure formalism, until it finally lost all influence.
The extent of the influence which Christianity exerted upon
Neo-Platonism is a greatly disputed point. We shall, perhaps, come
nearest the truth if we say that its influence was in the main not
direct, but that it was nevertheless real, inasmuch as it had
introduced problems up to that time undiscussed, with which
Neo-Platonism busied itself; in fact, it may almost be said that
Neo-Platonism was at first little more than (Aristotelian-) Platonism
busying itself with the new problems of salvation and redemption which
Christianity had thrown into the world of thought. It was un-Christian
at first (it became under Porphyry and later Neo-Platonists
anti-Christian), because it solved these problems in a way different
from the Christian way. This will explain the fact that all through,
whether in the more strictly philosophic system of Plotinus, or in the
more markedly religious and theurgic system of Jamblichus, there ran a
vein of mysticism, the conception of an intimate union with the supreme
God as the highest state to which man can attain.
Porphyry, with whom we are at
present concerned, was eminently practical in his thinking. The end of
philosophy with him was not knowledge, but holiness, the salvation of
the soul. He recommended a moderate asceticism as a chief means of
freeing the soul from the bonds of matter, and thus permitting it to
rise to union with God. At the same time, he did not advise the neglect
of the customary religious rites of Paganism, which might aid in the
elevation of the spirit of man toward the deity. It was with Porphyry
that Neo-Platonism first came into direct conflict with Christianity,
and its enmity against the latter goes far to explain the increasing
emphasis which he and the Neo-Platonists who followed him laid upon
religious rites and practices. Its philosophy, its solution of the
great problems of the age, was essentially and radically different from
that of Christianity; and although at first they might run alongside
one another as independent schools, without much thought of conflict,
it was inevitable that in time the rivalry, and then the active
hostility, should come. Neo-Platonism, like Christianity, had a
solution of the great problem of living to offer to the world,—in
an age of unexampled corruption, when thoughtful men were all seeking
for a solution,—and each was essentially exclusive of the other.
The attack, therefore, could not be long delayed. Porphyry seems to
have begun it in his famous work in fifteen books, now lost, which was
answered in extenso by Methodius of Tyre, Eusebius, and
Apolinarius of Laodicea. The answers, too, have perished; but from
extant fragments we are able to see that Porphyry’s attack was
very learned and able. He endeavored to point out the inconsistencies
in the sacred narrative, in order to discredit its divine origin. At
the same time, he treated Christ with the greatest respect, and ranked
him very high as a sage (though only human), and found much that was
good in his teaching. Augustine (De consensu Evang. I. 15) says
that the Neo-Platonists praised Christ, but railed at his disciples
(cf. Eusebius’ words in this chapter). Porphyry was a very
prolific writer; but only a few of his works are now extant, chief
among them the ἀφορμαὶ
πρὸς τὰ
νοητ€, or
Sententiæ, a brief but comprehensive exposition of his
philosophic system. We learn from this chapter that he had met Origen
when very young (he was but about twenty when Origen died); where, we
do not know. He lived to be at least sixty-eight years old (see his
Vita Plot. 23), and Suidas says that he died under Diocletian,
i.e. before 305 a.d.
On Porphyry and
Neo-Platonism in general, see the great works of Vacherot (Hist.
critique de l’Ecole d’Alexandrie) and Simon (Hist.
de l’Ecole d’Alexandrie); also Zeller’s
Philosophie der Griechen, and especially Erdmann’s
History of Philosophy (Engl. trans., London, 1889).