There have been some who have tried to reduce all the
great theological controversies on the Trinity and on the Incarnation
to mere logomachies, and have jeered at those who could waste their
time and energies over such trivialities. For example, it has
been said that the real difference
between Arius and Athanasius was nothing more nor less than an iota,
and that even Athanasius himself, in his more placid, and therefore
presumably more rational moods, was willing to hold communion with
those who differed from him and who still rejected the homousion.
But however catching and brilliant such remarks may be, they lack all
solid foundation in truth. It is perfectly manifest that a person
so entirely lacking in discrimination as not to see the enormous
difference between identity and likeness is not one whose opinion on
such a point can be of much value. A brilliant historian is not
necessarily an accurate historian, far less need he be a safe guide in
matters of theological definition. Cf. Bp.
Lightfoot’s criticism on Gibbon as an historian, The Apostolic
Fathers, Vol. I., p. 46 n. Macaulay’s History of
England will of course instantly present itself to the reader as a
sample of the brilliant variety of histories referred to in the
text.