you have received back men whom you condemned for the crime of schism by the “unerring
voice of your plenary Council” (I quote from the record), and replaced them in the same
episcopal sees as they were in at the time when you passed sentence against them? I refer to
Felicianus of Musti and Prætextatus of Assuri.1702 These were not, as you would have the
ignorant believe, included among those to whom your Council appointed and intimated a
certain time, after the lapse of which, if they had not returned to your communion, the
sentence would become final; but they were included among the others whom you con-
demned, without delay, on the day on which you gave to some, as I have said, a respite. I
can prove this, if you deny it. Your own Council is witness. We have also the proconsular
Acts, in which you have not once, but often, affirmed this. Provide, therefore, some other
line of defence if you can, lest, denying what I can prove, you cause loss of time. If, then,
Felicianus and Prætextatus were innocent, why were they thus condemned? If they were
guilty, why were they thus restored? If you prove them to have been innocent, can you object
to our believing that it was possible for innocent men, falsely charged with being traditors,
to be condemned by a much smaller number of your predecessors, if it is found possible for
innocent men, falsely charged with being schismatics, to be condemned by three hundred
and ten of their successors, whose decision is magniloquently described as proceeding from
“the unerring voice of a plenary Council”? If, however, you prove them to have been justly
condemned, what can you plead in defence of their being restored to office in the same
episcopal sees, unless, magnifying the importance and benefit of peace, you maintain that
even such things as these should be tolerated in order to preserve unbroken the bond of
unity? Would to God that you would urge this plea, not with the lips only, but with the
whole heart! You could not fail then to perceive that no calumnies whatever could justify
the breaking up of the peace of Christ throughout the world, if it is lawful in Africa for men,
once condemned for impious schism, to be restored to the same office which they held,
rather than break up the peace of Donatus and his party.
297
3. Again, you are wont to reproach us with persecuting you by the help of the civil power.
In regard to this, I do not draw an argument either from the demerit involved in the
enormity of so great an impiety, nor from the Christian meekness moderating the severity
of our measures. I take up this position: if this be a crime, why have you harshly persecuted
the Maximianists by the help of judges appointed by those emperors whose spiritual birth
by the gospel was due to our Church? Why have you driven them, by the din of controversy,
the authority of edicts, and the violence of soldiery, from those buildings for worship which
they possessed, and in which they were when they seceded from you? The wrongs endured
1702 Felicianus and Prætextatus were two of the twelve bishops by whom Maximianus was ordained. They
were condemned by the Donatist Council of Bagæ; but finding it impossible to eject them from their sees, the
Donatists yielded after a time, and restored them to their office. See Letter LIII. p. 299.
672
To Crispinus