The strong expressions of Chrys. concerning the community of goods
at Jerusalem are quite different from the guarded and limiting
statements of most modern commentators who seem bent upon showing that
it was only a case of remarkable liberality, e.g. Hackett in
loco: “Common in the use of their property, not necessarily
in their possession of it.” Our author’s statements agree
better with the New Test. notices on the subject. The main facts are
these. (1) There was a real and general community of property. The
statements in Acts on this point are clear and strong: καὶ
εἶχον ἅπαντα
κοινά (ii. 44); They were selling and
distributing their real and personal property—τὰ
κτήματα καὶ
τὰς
ὑπάρξεις (ii. 45). Nor did any one say that anything of his possessions was
his own, ἀλλ ἦν
αὐτοῖς
ἅπαντα
κοινά, (iv. 32); “As many as
(ὅσοι) were possessors of
lands or houses,” sold them, brought the money and distribution
was made to the needs of each (iv. 34,
35).
This is more than distinguished liberality or mere prevailing
willingness to give. (2) This peculiar phenomenon was connected with
the habit of living together as a group or family, on the part of the
Jerusalem Christians (i.
13; ii. 42–44). It was an evidence
that they were peculiarly one in heart and soul, that no member of this
closely-knit community was allowed to suffer while others could supply
him (iv. 32–34). (3) The
arrangement was purely voluntary. There was no law or demand in the
case. Ananias and Sapphira (v.
1–11) were not punished for contributing to the common treasury only a
part of the price of the land but as verse 4
clearly shows, for falsely presenting it as the
whole. Yet the fact that they wished to have it thought that they
had brought all seems to show that to bring all was customary and
expected. (4) This community of goods was both local and temporary. It
seems to have been confined to Jerusalem. There is no allusion to it in
the Epistles. It sprang out of the ardor of brotherly love in the early
years of the Christian community at Jerusalem and in view of the
special needs of many of its members. The special poverty of the church
at Jerusalem which made contributions from other churches necessary,
may have resulted in part, as Meyer suggests, from the working of this
plan. (5) The custom can hardly be explained apart from the expectation
of the nearness of the Parousia. In the Thessalonian church all
labor for self-support was upon the point of ceasing for the same
reason. 1 Thess. iii, 10,
sq.—G.B.S.