This position he had to defend against many
assailants, and especially against the Eunomians. These heretics
maintained that the use of this term necessarily implied a beginning of
the Essence of the Son, and they asked the orthodox to tell them when
that beginning took place. Gregory replies that the Generation of
God the Son is beyond all time; pointing out that Paternity is an
Essential attribute of God the Father, and therefore is as eternal as
His Essence, so that there never was a time when He was not the Father,
and consequently never a time when the Generation of the Son
began. He admits that there is a sense in which it is possible to
say that the Son and the Spirit are not unoriginate, but then you must
be careful not to use the word Origin in the sense of Beginning, but in
that of Cause. They derive Their Being eternally from the Father,
and all Three Persons are coeternal together. In respect of cause
They are not unoriginate, but the cause is not necessarily prior in
time to its effect, just as the Sun is not prior to its own
light. In respect of time, then, They may be said to be
unoriginate, for the Sources of time cannot be subject to time.
“If the Father has not ceased to beget, His Generation is an
imperfect one; and if He has ceased, He must have begun, for an end
implies a beginning.” “Not so,” says Gregory,
“unless you are prepared to admit that what has no end has
necessarily no beginning; and in that case what will you say about the
Angels, or the human soul? These will have no end; had either of
them therefore no beginning?” By a similar process
of Reductio ad absurdum he dissipates all the quibbles of
Eunomian sophistry, and lays down the orthodox Faith of the
Church. Then in the remainder of the Third and Fourth Orations he
goes on to examine the Scriptural testimony adduced by his opponents,
and to shew by a similar catena on the other side that the overwhelming
preponderance of the authority of the Bible is clearly against
them. In connection with this point he lays down the canon that
in the interpretation of Scripture in regard to our Lord, all
expressions savouring of humility or weakness are to be referred to
that pure Humanity which He assumed for our sake; while all that speaks
of Majesty and Power belongs to His Godhead.