Justin, in the passage quoted just below, is the first one to tell
us about Menander. According to him, he was a Samaritan and a disciple
of Simon Magus, and, like him, deceived many by the practice of magic
arts. Irenæus (Adv. Hær. I. 23) gives a somewhat
fuller account of him, very likely based upon Justin’s work
against heresies which the latter mentions in his Apol. I. 26,
and from which Irenæus quotes in IV. 6. 2 (at least he quotes from
a Contra Marcionem, which was in all probability a part of the
same work; see Bk. IV. chap. 11, note 22), and perhaps in V. 26. 2.
From this account of Irenæus that of Eusebius is drawn, and no new
particulars are added. Tertullian also mentions Menander (De
Anima, 23, 50) and his resurrection doctrine, but evidently knows
only what Irenæus has already told; and so the accounts of all the
early Fathers rest wholly upon Justin and Irenæus, and probably
ultimately upon Justin alone. See Salmon’s article
Menander in the Dict. of Christ. Biog.