Boox vu.] ARNOBIUS ADVERSUS GENTES. 311
with joy, and is elated capriciously with gladness.’ But the
gods should be free from both passions, if we would have
them to be everlasting, and freed from the weakness of
mortals. Moreover, every pleasure is, as it were, a kind of
flattery of the body, and is addressed to the five well-known
senses; but if the gods above feel it,’ they must partake also
of those bodies through which there is a way to the senses,
and a door [by which] to receive pleasures. Lastly, what
pleasure is it to take delight in the slaughter of harmless
creatures, to have the ears ringing often with their piteous
bellowings, to see rivers of blood, the life fleeing away with
the blood, and the secret parts having been laid open, not
only the intestines to protrude with the excrements, but
also the heart still bounding with the life left in it, and the
trembling, palpitating veins in the viscera? We half-savage
men, nay rather (to say with more candour what it is truer
and more candid to say), we savages, whom unhappy necessity
and bad habit have trained to take these as food, are some-
times moved with pity for them; we ourselves accuse and
condemn ourselves when the thing is seen and looked into
thoroughly, because, neglecting the law which is binding on
men, we have broken through the bonds which naturally
united us at the beginning? Will* any one believe that the
gods, [who are] kind, beneficent, gentle, are delighted and
filled with joy by the slaughter of cattle, if ever they fall and
expire pitiably before their altars?? And there is no cause,
then, for pleasure in sacrifices, as we see, nor is there a
reason why they should be offered, since there is no pleasure
[afforded by them]; and if perchance there is some, it has
been shown that it cannot in any way belong to the gods.
9. We have next to examine the argument which we hear
1 Lit., ** with the levities of gladnesses.” ? i.e. pleasure.
3 Naturalis initii consortia.
* So the Ms. and first ed., according to Ochler, reading cred-e-t, the
others -i- —‘‘ does.”
> Lit., ** these."
$ Arnobius says that the sacrifices give no pleasure to any being, or
at least, if that is not strictly true, that they give none to the gods.