skilful and prudential, then it follows necessarily that there is some plan in these things
bearing the mark of His wisdom, and at the same time of His providential care. A blind
unmeaning occurrence can never be the work of God; for it is the property of God, as the
Scripture says1538, to “make all things in wisdom.” What wisdom, then, can we trace in the
following? A human being enters on the scene of life, draws in the air, beginning the process
of living with a cry of pain, pays the tribute of a tear to Nature1539, just tastes life’s sorrows,
374
before any of its sweets have been his, before his feelings have gained any strength; still loose
in all his joints, tender, pulpy, unset; in a word, before he is even human (if the gift of reason
is man’s peculiarity, and he has never had it in him), such an one, with no advantage over
the embryo in the womb except that he has seen the air, so short-lived, dies and goes to
pieces again; being either exposed or suffocated, or else of his own accord ceasing to live
from weakness. What are we to think about him? How are we to feel about such deaths?
Will a soul such as that behold its Judge? Will it stand with the rest before the tribunal? Will
it undergo its trial for deeds done in life? Will it receive the just recompense by being purged,
according to the Gospel utterances, in fire, or refreshed with the dew of blessing1540? But I
do not see how we can imagine that, in the case of such a soul. The word “retribution” implies
that something must have been previously given; but he who has not lived at all has been
deprived of the material from which to give anything. There being, then, no retribution,
there is neither good nor evil left to expect. “Retribution” purports to be the paying back of
1538 Ps. civ. 24.
1539 ἐλειτούργησε τὸ δάκρυον
1540 There is introduced at these words in the text of the Paris Edition the following “Explicatio,” in Greek.
“Here it is manifest that the father means by the ‘purging fire’ the torments and agonies suffered by those who
having sinned have not completed a worthy and adequate repentance, according to the Gospel parable of the
Rich Man and Lazarus. For it is clear that he is thinking of this parable when he says, ‘either purged in fire’ (i.e.
the Rich Man), ‘or refreshed with the dew of blessing’ (i.e. Lazarus). But that sentence of the Judgment, ‘They
shall go, these into everlasting punishment, but the just into life everlasting,’ has no place as yet in these sufferings.”
In other words, the commentator sees here the doctrine of Purgatory, as held by the Roman Church. And when
we compare the other passages in Gregory about the “cleansing fire,” especially that De Animâ et Resurrectione,
247 B, we shall see that he contemplates the judgment (“the incorruptible tribunal”) as coming not only after
the Resurrection, but also after the chastising process. Not till the Judgment will the moral value of each life be
revealed; the chastising is a purely natural process. But then the belief in a Judgment coming after everything
rather contradicts the Universalism with which he has been charged, for what necessity would there be for it, if
the chastising was successful in every instance? With regard to the nature of this “fire,” it is spiritual or material
with him according to the context. The invisible natures will be punished with the one, the visible (i.e. the World)
with the other: although this destruction is not always preserved by him. See E. Moeller (on Gregory’s Doctrine
on Human Nature), p. 100.
693
On Infants' Early Deaths.