much upon, and that he handles with so much distinctness, explaining, giving reasons, and
answering objections.
Here it is not denied by any, that the apostle does assert, that we are justified by faith,
without the works of the law, because the words are express; but only it is said that we take
his words wrong, and understand that by them that never entered into his heart, in that
when he excludes the works of the law, we understand him of the whole law of God, or the
rule which he has given to mankind to walk by; whereas all that he intends is the ceremonial.
Some that oppose this doctrine indeed say, that the apostle sometimes means that it is
by faith, i.e. a hearty embracing the gospel in its first act only, or without any preceding holy
life, that persons are admitted into a justified state; but, say they, it is by a persevering
obedience that they are continued in a justified state, and it is by this that they are finally
justified. But this is the same thing as to say, that a man on his first embracing the gospel is
conditionally justified and pardoned. To pardon sin, is to free the sinner from the punishment
of it, or from that eternal misery that is due to it; and therefore if a person is pardoned, or
freed from this misery, on his first embracing the gospel, and yet not finally freed, but his
actual freedom still depends on some condition yet to be performed, it is inconceivable how
he can be pardoned otherwise than conditionally; that is, he is not properly actually pardoned,
and freed from punishment, but only he has God’s promise that he shall be pardoned on
future conditions. God promises him, that now, if he perseveres in obedience, he shall be
finally pardoned, or actually freed from hell; which is to make just nothing at all of the
apostle’s great doctrine of justification by faith alone. Such a conditional pardon is no pardon
or justification at all, any more than all mankind have, whether they embrace the gospel or
no; for they all have a promise of final justification on conditions of future sincere obedience,
as much as he that embraces the gospel. But not to dispute about this, we will suppose that
there may be something or other at the sinner’s first embracing the gospel, that may properly
be called justification or pardon, and yet that final justification, or real freedom from the
punishment of sin, is still suspended on conditions hitherto unfulfilled; yet they who hold
that sinners are thus justified on embracing the gospel, suppose that they are justified by
this, no otherwise than as it is a leading act of obedience, or at least as virtue and moral
goodness in them, and therefore would be excluded by the apostle as much as any other
virtue or obedience, if it be allowed that he means the moral law, when he excludes works
of the law. And therefore, if that point be yielded, that the apostle means the moral, and not
only the ceremonial, law, their whole scheme falls to the ground.
And because the issue of the whole argument from those texts in St. Paul’s epistles de-
pends on the determination of this point, I would be particular in the discussion of it.
Some of our opponents in this doctrine of justification, when they deny, that by the law
the apostle means the moral law, or the whole rule of life which God has given to mankind,
seem to choose to express themselves thus, that the apostle only intends the Mosaic dispens-
2310
DISCOURSE. I. Justification by Faith alone.