Peter’s vision fitly represents the divine lesson concerning
the destination of the gospel and the manner of its progress. None of
the apostles doubted that Christianity was for the Gentiles: the great
question was, whether it was to be preached to them through the medium
of Judaism. Should it still be held within Jewish forms? Should
circumcision and observance of the Mosaic law be required? This was a
great practical question in the days of transition from Judaism to
Christianity. Later Paul became the champion of the idea that it was to
be cut loose from the Jewish system. Peter and James came but slowly to
this idea. The destruction of Jerusalem and the fall of the Jewish
state brought the question to a decisive settlement. Apart from this,
however, the Pauline type of teaching on this point constantly gained
ground and influence. The vision of Peter takes its place in the
gradual development of the idea that Christianity was free from the
law—an idea on which he seems after this to have held a somewhat
uncertain and vacillating position, so that Paul “resisted him to
the face” for his declining to eat with the Gentiles at Antioch
on account of the presence of certain delegates from Jerusalem—a
practice in which he had, before their coming, engaged (Gal. ii. 11, 12).
It is not strange that perplexing questions arose concerning the
relations of the new system to the old at this time. The general line
of procedure was settled by the apostolic conference at Jerusalem
(Acts xv., Gal. i., ii.) and was
substantially determined by the apostle Paul. While as matter of fact,
the Church has always followed the lead of Paul in this matter, the
most diverse views still prevail among Christians as to the relation,
theoretically considered, of Christianity to Judaism and the Old
Testament Scriptures.—G.B.S.