119
Disputation of the Second Day.
The next day, a notary having again been summoned, the discussion was conducted as
follows:
Fortunatus said: I say that God Almighty brings forth from Himself nothing evil, and
that the things that are His remain incorrupt, having sprung and being born from an invi-
olable source; but other contrary things which have their being in this world, do not flow
from God nor have appeared in this world with God as their author; that is to say, they do
not derive their origin from God. These things therefore we have received in the belief that
evil things are foreign to God.
20. Augustin said: And our faith is this, that God is not the progenitor of evil things,
neither has He made any evil nature. But since both of us agree that God is incorruptible
and incontaminable, it is the part of the prudent and faithful to consider, which faith is
purer and worthier of the majesty of God; that in which it is asserted that either the power
of God, or some part of God, or the Word of God, can be changed, violated, corrupted,
fettered; or that in which it is said that Almighty God and His entire nature and substance
can never be corrupted in any part, but that evils have their being by the voluntary sin of
the soul, to which God gave free will. Which free will if God had not given, there could be
no just penal judgment, nor merit of righteous conduct, nor divine instruction to repent of
sins, nor the forgiveness of sins itself which God has bestowed upon us through our Lord
Jesus Christ. Because he who sins not voluntarily, sins not at all. This I suppose to be open
and perspicuous to all. Wherefore it ought not to trouble us if according to our deserts we
suffer some inconveniences in the things God has made. For as He is good, that He should
constitute all things; so He is just, that He may not spare sins, which sins, as I have said,
unless free will were in us, would not be sins. For if any one, so to speak, should be bound
by some one in his other members, and with his hand something false should be written
without his own will, I ask whether if this were laid open before a judge, he could condemn
this one for the crime of falsehood. Wherefore, if it is manifest that there is no sin where
there is not free exercise of will,242 I wish to hear what evil the soul which you call either
part, or power, or word, or something else, of God, has done, that it should be punished by
God, or repent of sin, or merit forgiveness, since it has in no way sinned?
Fortunatus said: I proposed concerning substances, that God is to be regarded as creator
only of good things, but as the avenger of evil things, for the reason that evil things are not
of Him. Therefore for good reason I think this, and that God avenges evil things because
they are not of Himself. But if they were from Him, either He would give them license to
sin, as you say that God has given free will, He would be already found a participator in my
fault, because He would be the author of my fault; or ignorant what I should be, he left me
242 Liberum voluntatis arbitrium.
Disputation of the Second Day.
198
Disputation of the Second Day.