Such were the more enduring results of the recall
of the exiled bishops by Julian; results very different from what he
contemplated in recalling them. Apparently before the date of the
council he had written to the Alexandrians (Ep. 26), explaining
that he had recalled the exiles to their countries, not to their sees,
and directing that Athanasius, who ought after so many sentences
against him to have asked special permission to return, should leave
the City at once on pain of severer punishment. An appeal seems to have
been made against this order by the people of Alexandria, but without
effect. Pending the appeal Athanasius apparently felt safe in remaining
in the town, and carrying out the measures described above. In October
(it would seem) Julian wrote an indignant letter to the Prefect
Ecdikius Olympus (Sievers, p. 124), threatening a heavy fine if
Athanasius, ‘the enemy of the gods,’ did not leave not only
Alexandria, but Egypt, at once. He adds an angry comment on his having
dared to baptize ‘in my reign’ Greek ladies of rank
(Ep. 6). Another letter (Ep. 51) to the people of
Alexandria, along with arguments in favour of Serapis and the gods, and
against Christ, reiterates the order for Athanasius to leave Egypt by
Dec. 1. Julian’s somewhat petulant reference to the bishop as a
‘contemptible little fellow’ ill conceals his evident
feeling that Athanasius, who had ‘coped with Constantius like a
king battling with a king’ (Greg. Naz.), was in Egypt a power
greater than himself. But no man has ever wielded such political power
as Athanasius with so little disposition to use it. He bowed his head
to the storm and prepared to leave Alexandria once more (Oct. 23). His
friends stood round lamenting their loss. ‘Be of good
heart,’ he replied, ‘it is only a cloud, and will soon pass
away’ (Soz. v. 14). He took a Nile boat, and set off toward Upper
Egypt, but finding that he was tracked by the government officers he
directed the boat’s course to be reversed. Presently they met
that of the pursuers, who suspecting nothing asked for news of
Athanasius. ‘He is not far off’ was the answer, given
according to one account by Athanasius himself (Thdt. iii. 9, Socr.
iii. 14). He returned to Chæreu, the first station on the road
eastward from Alexandria (as is inferred from the Thereu or Thereon of
Hist. Aceph. vii., viii.; but the identification is merely
conjectural; for Chæreu cf. Itin. and Vit. Ant. 86),
and after danger of pursuit was over, ‘ascended to the upper
parts of Egypt as far as Upper Hermupolis in the Thebaid and as far as
Antinoupolis; and while he abode in these places it was learned that
Julian the Emperor was dead, and that Jovian, a Christian, was
Emperor’ (Hist. Aceph.). Of his stay in the Thebaid (cf.
Fest. Ind. xxxv.) some picturesque details are preserved in the
life of Pachomius and the letter of Ammon (on which see below, p. 487).
As he approached Hermupolis, the bishops, clergy, and monks
(‘about 100 in number’) of the Thebaid lined both banks of
the river to welcome him. ‘Who are these,’ he exclaimed,
‘that fly as a cloud and as doves with their young ones’ (Isa. lx. 8, LXX). Then he
saluted the Abbat Theodore, and asked after the brethren. ‘By thy
holy prayers, Father, we are well.’ He was mounted on an ass and
escorted to the monastery with burning torches (they ‘almost set
fire to him’), the abbat walking before him on foot. He inspected
the monasteries, and expressed his high approval of all he heard and
saw, and when Theodore, upon departing for his Easter (363)
visitation Krüger, in Theol. Litzg. 1890, p. 620 sqq.,
fixes the death of Theodore for Easter 363, on the ground, as I venture
to think, of a date (345) for the death of Pachomius too early by one
year. The question is too intricate to discuss here, but with all
deference to so competent a critic, I am confident that Theodore lived
till at any rate the following Easter. See infr. p. 569, note
3. of the brethren, asked ‘the
Pope’ to remember him in his prayers, the answer was
characteristic: ‘If we forget thee, O Jerusalem’ (Vit.
Pachom. 92, see p. 569). About midsummer he was near Antinoupolis,
and trusted messengers warned him that the pursuers were again upon his
track. Theodore brought his covered boat to escort him up to Tabenne,
and in company with an ‘abbat’ called Pammon they made
their way slowly against wind and stream. Athanasius became much
alarmed and prayed earnestly to himself, while Theodore’s monks
towed the boat from the shore. Athanasius, in reply to an encouraging
remark of Pammon, spoke of the peace of mind he felt when under
persecution, and of the consolation of suffering and even death for
Christ’s sake. Pammon looked at Theodore, and they smiled, barely
restraining a laugh. ‘You think me a coward,’ said
Athanasius. ‘Tell him,’ said Theodore to Pammon. ‘No,
you must tell him.’ Theodore then announced to the
astonished archbishop that at that very hour Julian had been killed in
Persia, and that he should lose no time in making his way to the new
Christian Emperor, who would restore him to the Church. The story
(below, p. 487) implies rather than expressly states that the day and
hour tallied exactly with the death of Julian, June 26, 363. This story
is, on the whole, the best attested of the many legends of the kind
which surround the mysterious end of the unfortunate prince. (Cf. Thdt.
H. E. iii. 23, Soz. vi. 2. For the religious policy of Julian
and his relation to Church history, see Rendall’s Julian
and the full and excellent article by Wordsworth in D.C.B. iii.
484–525.)