The Chron. puts the accession of Asclepiades in the first
year of Caracalla (211 a.d.). Harnack (Zeit
des Ignatius, p. 47) believes that this notice rests upon better
knowledge than the notices of most of the Antiochian bishops, because
in this case the author departs from the artificial scheme which he
follows in the main. But Harnack contends that the date is not quite
correct, because Alexander, who suffered under Severus, was still in
prison when Asclepiades became bishop, and therefore the latter’s
accession must be put back into Severus’ reign. He would fix,
therefore, upon about 209 as the date of it, rightly perceiving that
there is good reason for thinking the Chron. at least nearly
correct in its report, and that in any case his accession cannot be
carried back much beyond that, because it is quite probable (from the
congratulations which Alexander extends to the church of Antioch) that
there had been a vacancy in that church for some time after the death
of Serapion (a thing not at all unnatural in the midst of the
persecutions of the time), while Serapion was still alive as late as
203 (see Bk. V. chap. 19, note 1). But it seems to me that there is no
good ground for making any alteration in the date given by the
Chron., for we know that at the very end of Severus’ reign
the persecution broke out again with considerable severity, and that it
continued, at least in Africa, for some time after Caracalla’s
accession (see Tertullian’s ad Scap.). The general amnesty
issued by Caracalla after the murder of his brother Geta in 212 (see
Dion Cassius, LXXVII. 3) seems first to have put a definitive end to
the persecutions. There is therefore no ground for confining
Alexander’s imprisonment to the reign of Severus. It may well
have run into the time of Caracalla, and hence it is quite possible
that Asclepiades did not become bishop until after the latter became
emperor, so that it is not necessary to correct the date of the
Chron. It is impossible to determine with certainty the length
of Asclepiades’ episcopate (see chap. 21, note 6). Of Asclepiades
himself we know no more than is told us in this chapter. He seems to
have been a man of most excellent character, to judge from
Alexander’s epistle. That epistle, of course, was written
immediately after Asclepiades’ appointment.